
Strategic KAIZEN™
12 minUsing Flow, Synchronization, and Leveling (FSL™) Assessment to Measure and Strengthen Operational Performance
Introduction
Narrator: Imagine one of the world's largest companies, General Motors, getting a direct, hands-on masterclass from its most formidable competitor, Toyota. From 1984 to 2009, they ran a joint venture factory in California called NUMMI. The plant, once one of GM's worst, was transformed by Toyota's methods into a beacon of productivity and quality. GM managers cycled through, witnessing the magic of the Toyota Production System firsthand. Yet, when GM faced bankruptcy in 2009 and was bailed out with the explicit mandate to fundamentally change, it failed. Suppliers reported that the "New GM" was indistinguishable from the old one. Why would a company with a 25-year, front-row seat to a superior system refuse to learn?
This perplexing failure is at the heart of Masaaki Imai's groundbreaking book, Strategic KAIZEN™: Using Flow, Synchronization, and Leveling (FSL™) Assessment to Measure and Strengthen Operational Performance. Imai, the global authority who introduced the concept of kaizen to the West, argues that the answer isn't about tools or techniques. It’s about a profound, strategic failure at the highest levels of leadership—a failure to see beyond short-term metrics and embrace a fundamentally different way of running a business.
The Foundational Flaw: Why 99% of Companies Are Stuck in the Past
Key Insight 1
Narrator: Masaaki Imai posits a stark reality: an estimated 99% of companies today operate as "traditional" organizations, trapped by century-old legacies that prioritize volume and speed above all else. This traditional model is built on a foundation of sales forecasts, which are notoriously inaccurate. The result is a vicious cycle of overproduction, leading to mountains of costly inventory, or underproduction, leading to missed sales and dissatisfied customers.
The stark difference between this approach and a lean one is vividly illustrated by the early experiences of Charlie Sharman, a contributor to the book. Working in the UK's automotive industry in the 1970s, Sharman witnessed a culture where quality was routinely sacrificed to meet production deadlines. His job involved collecting defective products from customers every Friday for rework. The focus was on pushing volume out the door to avoid penalties, creating immense waste and inefficiency. This was the traditional system in action. It wasn't until he read Imai's first book and saw the arrival of Japanese car manufacturers that he understood a different way was possible—one built not on forecasts and firefighting, but on continuous improvement, or kaizen. Lean companies, in contrast, employ minimum resources for maximum output by focusing relentlessly on eliminating waste and creating a smooth, uninterrupted flow driven by actual customer orders, not forecasts.
The Leadership Blind Spot: Prioritizing Shareholders Over a Sustainable System
Key Insight 2
Narrator: Why do so many companies remain stuck in this inefficient traditional model? Imai argues the blame lies squarely with the CEO and the board. The core issue is a deep-seated confusion between two different worlds: the "real market" and the "expectations market." The real market is where products are designed, built, and sold to actual customers. The expectations market is the stock market, where investor sentiment shapes a company's share price. Modern corporate governance, particularly the agency theory, has pushed executives to prioritize the expectations market, focusing on short-term shareholder delight over the long-term health of the real market.
The tragic story of General Motors serves as the ultimate cautionary tale. Despite the 25-year-long NUMMI joint venture with Toyota, which demonstrated the clear superiority of lean operational principles, GM never truly adopted them. When the 2009 crisis hit, the company focused on financial restructuring—layoffs, debt reduction, and downsizing—but neglected the far more critical operational restructuring. Why? Because improving operational flow doesn't produce the immediate, dramatic stock-price jolts that Wall Street rewards. The leadership, driven by short-term incentives, failed to make the long-term strategic commitment to operational excellence. They had the blueprint for success right in front of them for decades but chose to ignore it, a decision that ultimately led to their collapse.
The Gemba Revolution: The Turnaround of KOA Industry
Key Insight 3
Narrator: While GM represents a failure of leadership, the case of KOA Industry shows what is possible when a leader embraces a new perspective. In the 1980s, KOA, a Japanese electronics manufacturer, was in a deep crisis. Its president, Koichi Mukaiyama, had pursued a strategy of high-tech automation and large-scale production. But when economic conditions shifted, the company was left with plummeting profits and a mountain of unsold inventory.
Frustrated, Mukaiyama began visiting other companies and, crucially, his own factory floors—the gemba, or the "real place" where work happens. What he saw shocked him. He found three months' worth of product inventory sitting idle, representing immense wasted capital. He realized his focus on numbers on a desk had disconnected him from his customers and his own operations. This led to a dramatic "shock remedy." All inventory from sales branches was recalled to the corporate gymnasium, where sales staff were forced to classify it as sellable or scrap. The vast majority was scrapped. This painful but powerful event forced everyone to see the physical reality of their waste. Inspired by the Toyota Production System, Mukaiyama launched the KOA Production System (KPS), a gemba-centric approach focused on eliminating waste, reducing inventory, and empowering employees on the shop floor. This turnaround was not driven by a new technology, but by a leader's courage to confront reality at the gemba.
The Hidden Engine of Lean: Flow, Synchronization, and Leveling (FSL)
Key Insight 4
Narrator: At the core of Imai's work is a new framework for assessing a company's operational health: Flow, Synchronization, and Leveling (FSL). These are the "hidden secrets" of a lean strategy, moving beyond vague notions of "efficiency" to provide concrete criteria for excellence.
- Flow is the smooth, continual, and swift movement of work from the beginning of a process to the end, without interruption or delay. Any stoppage is a problem to be solved. * Synchronization means that all processes are aligned with each other and, most importantly, with customer orders. The ideal is a "one-piece flow," where a single item moves seamlessly through the system. * Leveling, or heijunka, is the practice of smoothing out the inevitable peaks and valleys of customer demand to create a predictable, stable, and manageable workload.
The case of Yokomori Manufacturing, a stairway maker, perfectly illustrates the power of FSL. Initially, their factory was in chaos. Piles of materials were everywhere, and operators spent most of their time moving parts around. They were even planning to build a costly new warehouse to store all their excess inventory. A consultant advised them to cancel the warehouse and instead focus on creating flow. By implementing leveling (heijunka) to match production schedules with on-site assembly needs, they transformed their chaotic job shop into a smooth flow shop. This eliminated the need for massive inventories and dramatically reduced costs, proving that the solution wasn't more space, but better flow.
Beyond the Factory Walls: The Toyota Philosophy of Partnership
Key Insight 5
Narrator: A true lean strategy extends beyond a company's own four walls. It requires a fundamental shift in how it views its suppliers. The traditional Western model often treats suppliers as adversaries in a zero-sum game of cost negotiation. The Toyota philosophy, however, sees them as long-term partners.
A story from former Toyota chairman Fujio Cho powerfully illustrates this. Early in his career, Cho was in charge of an office for "temporary outsourcing." When Toyota's plants were too busy, his office would farm out work to suppliers, only to take it back once capacity returned. When the legendary Taiichi Ohno, the father of the Toyota Production System, learned of this, he was furious. He told Cho, "Remember, even if the contract lasts only for one month, the supplier must prepare manpower, material, and machines. If you terminate the order after one month, what happens to them?" Ohno immediately shut the office down. His point was clear: suppliers are not disposable resources. They are partners who invest based on your orders, and they must be treated with respect. This philosophy of building a deeply integrated, mutually beneficial ecosystem is a cornerstone of lean's long-term, sustainable success.
Conclusion
Narrator: The single most important takeaway from Strategic KAIZEN™ is that lean is not a project, a tool, or a departmental initiative. It is a corporate strategy that must be driven with unwavering commitment from the absolute top of the organization. The failure to adopt lean is rarely a failure of knowledge or opportunity; it is a failure of leadership to look beyond the seductive allure of short-term financial engineering and commit to the hard, patient work of building a truly resilient and efficient operational system.
Imai's work challenges us with a difficult question: If the principles of lean are so demonstrably powerful, why do so few organizations truly embrace them? The answer lies in our inability to measure what matters most. We have rigorous systems for auditing financial performance, but almost none for operational health. Perhaps the most profound challenge the book leaves us with is to start asking not just "How did our stock perform this quarter?" but "How is our flow? Are we synchronized with our customers? And is our system level and stable?" Only when those questions are given equal weight in the boardroom can a company truly begin its journey toward lasting excellence.