
Flexible Working
11 minHow to implement flexibility in the workplace to improve employee and business performance
Introduction
Narrator: Every weekday morning, in cities across the globe, millions of people perform a familiar, frustrating ritual. They wake early, rush through their morning, and join a mass exodus, packing onto crowded trains or sitting in gridlocked traffic. This daily commute consumes time, money, and energy, contributing to stress and a massive carbon footprint, all to arrive at a specific building to perform tasks that technology often allows them to do from anywhere. This begs the question: Is this inherited model of work, a relic from the Industrial Revolution, truly the most sensible way to operate in the 21st century?
In her book, Flexible Working: How to implement flexibility in the workplace to improve employee and business performance, author Gemma Dale not only argues that this model is profoundly outdated but also provides a comprehensive and practical guide for organizations to build a more effective, humane, and profitable future. The book dismantles the myths holding businesses back and lays out a clear roadmap for a flexible working revolution.
The 9-to-5 Blueprint Is a Broken Relic
Key Insight 1
Narrator: The book begins by establishing a foundational truth: the traditional 9-to-5, Monday-to-Friday, office-centric model of work is no longer fit for purpose. This structure was designed for the industrial age, a time when work required physical presence on a production line. Today, for a vast number of knowledge workers, the nature of work has fundamentally changed, yet the structure remains stubbornly in place.
Dale argues that this resistance to change is not based on logic but on tradition and a lack of imagination. The daily commute story vividly illustrates the inefficiency and human cost of this model. Despite technological advancements that make remote and asynchronous work possible, many organizations cling to "presenteeism"—the belief that an employee's value is tied to their physical presence in the office. This outdated mindset ignores the clear benefits of allowing employees to work when, where, and how they are most productive. The book frames the move towards flexibility not as a radical new idea, but as a long-overdue correction to a system that no longer serves employees or the businesses that employ them.
The Overwhelming Business Case for Flexibility
Key Insight 2
Narrator: Moving beyond the problems with the old model, Dale builds a powerful, evidence-based case for the benefits of flexible working. This is not presented as a mere employee perk but as a potent strategic advantage. The data is compelling: one global study by IWG found that 85% of businesses reported their productivity increased as a result of greater flexibility.
The benefits create a virtuous cycle. For employees, flexibility leads to better work-life balance, reduced stress, and greater autonomy, which in turn boosts engagement and job satisfaction. For organizations, this translates directly into improved performance. A 2018 XpertHR survey found that employers cited improved employee retention and engagement as the highest-rated benefits of flexible working.
The case study of Zurich Insurance Group brings this to life. Recognizing the changing needs of its workforce, Zurich implemented a program called 'FlexWork,' making all vacancies available as potential part-time, job-share, or full-time flexible roles. The results were transformative. Employee engagement rose, and the company saw a significant increase in female applicants for senior management positions, directly addressing diversity goals. Zurich’s success demonstrates that when flexibility is embedded in the culture, it becomes a powerful tool for attracting top talent and driving business success.
A Powerful Engine for Inclusion and Equality
Key Insight 3
Narrator: Perhaps the book's most profound argument is that flexible working is a critical tool for social justice. Its impact extends far beyond convenience, creating more equitable and inclusive workplaces for groups often marginalized by the rigid 9-to-5 structure.
Dale dedicates significant analysis to the link between flexibility and gender equality. The "motherhood penalty," where women's careers stagnate after having children, is often exacerbated by a lack of quality part-time or flexible roles. By normalizing flexibility, organizations can help dismantle this barrier. Furthermore, it challenges traditional gender roles. A 2019 Deloitte survey of millennial fathers revealed that one-third had already changed jobs for more flexibility, and another third were considering it. When men are empowered to work flexibly to share caring responsibilities, it tackles gender stereotypes at their source.
The benefits ripple outwards to include employees with disabilities, who may find commuting or a standard workday physically challenging; carers, who are often forced to choose between their job and their responsibilities; and older workers, who can use flexible arrangements like phased retirement to remain in the workforce longer, allowing organizations to retain their valuable skills and experience.
Dismantling the Cultural Walls of Resistance
Key Insight 4
Narrator: Despite the clear benefits, many organizations remain resistant. Dale argues that the primary barriers are not practical but cultural, rooted in deeply ingrained myths and a lack of trust. One of the most pervasive is the myth of the "ideal worker"—an employee who is always available and prioritizes work above all else. This outdated archetype fuels "flexism," a form of discrimination where flexible workers are unfairly perceived as less committed or ambitious.
Managers are often the gatekeepers who either enable or block progress. Their reluctance can stem from a fear of losing control, concerns about fairness, or simply a lack of training in how to manage for outcomes rather than presence. The book stresses that flexible working is built on trust. Cultures that demand physical presence to ensure productivity are fundamentally cultures of distrust. To overcome this, organizations must reframe flexibility as a mutual advantage and actively work to debunk myths with data and success stories.
The Six Pillars of a Truly Flexible Workplace
Key Insight 5
Narrator: To move from a rigid culture to a flexible one, Dale outlines six essential elements that must be in place. These pillars form the foundation for a sustainable and effective flexible working environment. 1. Flexibility for Everyone: It must be the default for as many roles as possible, not a special privilege for a select few. This prevents a "two-tier" system and reduces stigma. 2. Acceptance of All Forms: Organizations should embrace a wide spectrum of arrangements, from remote work and flexi-time to job-sharing and compressed hours. 3. High Trust: The culture must shift from monitoring inputs (hours worked) to measuring outputs (results achieved). 4. Enabling Managers and Leaders: Leaders must not only approve policies but also act as role models and champions for flexibility. 5. Effective Policy: Policies should be simple, supportive, and go beyond the legal minimum, empowering managers to find solutions. 6. Enabling Technology: The right tools are crucial to ensure remote workers can collaborate effectively and remain connected to their teams.
These six elements work together to create an ecosystem where flexibility can thrive, moving it from a series of one-off exceptions to the cultural norm.
The Strategic Journey from Policy to Practice
Key Insight 6
Narrator: The final piece of the puzzle is a deliberate and strategic implementation. Dale provides a practical guide, emphasizing that simply writing a policy is not enough. The journey involves a readiness assessment to understand the current culture, securing genuine buy-in from senior leaders, and setting clear, measurable goals.
Manager training is identified as the single most effective way to increase both the quantity and quality of flexible working. Managers need the skills to lead remote teams, manage performance based on results, and facilitate inclusive communication. The book also recommends proactive measures like establishing flexible working champions, sharing success stories, and creating networking groups to provide ongoing support and maintain momentum. As the case study of the public-sector IT department's 'Work Anywhere' program showed, consulting with employees and providing targeted guidance are key to a successful rollout that improves engagement and achieves business aims.
Conclusion
Narrator: The single most important takeaway from Flexible Working is that flexibility is no longer a fringe benefit or a simple HR policy; it is a fundamental business strategy for the modern era. The book compellingly argues that the future of work must be built on a foundation of trust and a focus on outcomes, not on the outdated principles of time and location. It requires a profound cultural shift from monitoring presence to empowering performance.
The COVID-19 pandemic forced a global, unplanned experiment in remote work, proving that many long-held assumptions about the necessity of the office were false. The real challenge for organizations now is to be intentional. Will they revert to the familiar but flawed models of the past, or will they seize this historic opportunity to consciously design a more effective, inclusive, and human-centered way of working? The future, as Gemma Dale makes clear, belongs to those who choose to be flexible.