Aibrary Logo
Podcast thumbnail

You Weren’t Supposed To See That

10 min

Introduction

Narrator: Imagine you own a small chain of grocery stores. For years, your business has been your life's work. But now, a titan of industry, Amazon, is entering the grocery business. You’ve seen what happened to bookstores, record shops, and electronics retailers. You know the fight is unwinnable. So, what do you do? Do you invest every last dollar into your stores to try and compete? Or do you do something else entirely? The owner in this real-life scenario made a radical choice: he took his capital and bought Amazon stock. Instead of fighting the disruptor, he invested in it. This wasn't a move driven by greed, but by terror—the cold, rational fear of being left behind.

This single anecdote cuts to the heart of the modern economy, a landscape of hidden forces and uncomfortable truths explored in Joshua M. Brown's book, You Weren’t Supposed To See That. Brown, a 15-year veteran of the financial world, pulls back the curtain to reveal that the rules we thought we knew have been fundamentally rewritten.

The New Investment Engine is Fear, Not Greed

Key Insight 1

Narrator: For decades, market psychology was understood through the simple lens of fear and greed. Greed drove bubbles, and fear caused crashes. But Brown argues that a new, more powerful emotion is now at the wheel: the fear of obsolescence. The primary driver of the massive run-up in technology stocks, what Brown calls the "fear-based investment bubble," is not the desire for riches but the terror of being made irrelevant by automation, software, and artificial intelligence.

This is illustrated perfectly by the grocery store owner who chose to buy Amazon stock rather than reinvest in his own business. He saw the future and realized it was more prudent to own a piece of the machine that was coming to replace him. This same logic is playing out on a massive scale. Investors are piling into the "Magnificent Seven"—companies like Apple, Microsoft, and Nvidia—not just because they see opportunity, but because they see these companies as the architects of a future that will displace countless jobs and industries. Investing in them becomes a form of survival, a life raft in a sea of technological disruption. As Brown puts it, people are asking themselves, "What multiple would you pay to survive?" The answer is driving one of a in four investment dollars in the US stock market into just seven companies. The mantra is no longer "get rich," but as Brown's chapter title bluntly states, "Just own the damn robots."

The Pandemic Accidentally Revealed a Broken System

Key Insight 2

Narrator: The book's title, You Weren’t Supposed to See That, refers to a massive, unintentional economic experiment that occurred during the COVID-19 pandemic. Before 2020, the economy operated under a clear hierarchy. The wealthy leveraged low interest rates and rising asset prices to grow their fortunes, while the working class had limited options and significant obligations.

Then, the pandemic hit. To prevent a second Great Depression, the government unleashed trillions of dollars in stimulus, sending direct payments to individuals and families. For a brief moment, this experiment "worked too well." With newfound financial freedom, millions of people quit jobs they hated, started their own ventures, or simply took time off. This created a labor shortage that gave workers unprecedented bargaining power, leading to higher wages and better conditions. For the first time in a generation, the system was tilted, however slightly, away from capital and toward labor.

According to Brown, this was the moment "you weren’t supposed to see." Widespread prosperity and flexibility for the masses broke the established economic order. The subsequent "War on Inflation," he argues, is not merely an economic policy but a deliberate effort to restore the pre-pandemic hierarchy. By raising interest rates and engineering a slowdown, policymakers are willing to sacrifice the economic well-being of the working class to curb their bargaining power and return to the "normal" of 2019, where the options belonged to the few and the obligations to the many.

The Market's Mechanics Have Fundamentally Changed

Key Insight 3

Narrator: Many investors have noticed a strange phenomenon in recent years: a "relentless bid" where every market dip is almost instantly bought. Brown explains that this isn't just sentiment; it's a structural change in the market. The financial advisory industry has undergone a massive shift from a commission-based model to a fee-based one.

In the old model, brokers made money from transactions, encouraging active trading. Today, most advisors charge a percentage of the assets they manage. This incentivizes them to grow their clients' assets steadily over the long term, not to churn the portfolio. The result is a constant, automated flow of money into the market, primarily into passive index funds and ETFs. This creates a powerful, persistent buying pressure that dampens volatility and makes corrections shallower.

However, this automation has a strange side effect. While the market hits record highs, the euphoria that typically accompanies a bull market is absent. Brown attributes this to the very force driving the relentless bid: technology. Automation and the rise of passive investing are leading to widespread job insecurity on Wall Street. Traders, analysts, and even IPO bankers are being replaced by algorithms. The industry is no longer a place of extravagant parties and lavish bonuses, but one of quiet anxiety. The market, as Brown describes it, is "35% passive and 65% terrified," a dynamic that paradoxically helps sustain the rally by preventing the kind of irrational exuberance that leads to bubbles.

Intangible Value Has Dethroned Physical Assets

Key Insight 4

Narrator: For most of history, a company's value was tied to its tangible assets—its factories, machinery, and inventory. This was its "book value." But in an era of near-zero interest rates, capital became cheap, and this old logic was turned on its head. Brown argues that the most valuable assets are now the ones you can't count: brand, intellectual property, and network effects.

Companies like Airbnb, with no hotels, became more valuable than established chains like Marriott. Uber, with no cars, surpassed the valuation of Ford. Investors were no longer buying physical assets; they were buying ideas and user bases. Brown satirizes this environment with the hypothetical "Hundred Dollar Bill Store™," a business that sells $100 bills for $90. It loses money on every transaction but shows incredible revenue and user growth, making it a prime candidate for a multi-billion dollar IPO.

This era of "free capital" rewarded growth at all costs and punished traditional, asset-heavy companies. However, with the Federal Reserve now aggressively raising interest rates, a reckoning is underway. The "anything goes" era is over, and companies are being forced to focus on profitability once again. The question Brown leaves open is whether this is a temporary correction or a permanent return to valuing things we can actually touch.

The Primal Emotions of Investing Have Evolved

Key Insight 5

Narrator: The legendary trader Jesse Livermore once said that markets are driven by greed, fear, ignorance, and hope. While these emotions still exist, Brown contends they have mutated into new, more modern forms, amplified by the constant connectivity of social media.

The new fear is Insecurity—the fear of being left behind, or FOMO. Watching cryptocurrencies and meme stocks soar created a powerful anxiety among those on the sidelines, pushing them to take risks they otherwise wouldn't. The new greed is Envy. In the hyper-visible world of "Financial Twitter," success isn't enough; the real prize is watching others who disagreed with you fail. The desire for others to feel the pain of not having been right becomes a more potent driver than personal gain.

This transforms the market from a competition for profits into a global-scale "Squid Game," where millions of anonymous participants are driven by envy and insecurity. The speculative mania of 2020-2021, fueled by these emotions, ended in a predictable crash. The envy directed at winners quickly curdled into disgust and recrimination, with blame cast on influencers and promoters. Brown concludes that while the technologies and platforms change, the underlying human emotions that drive these cycles of boom and bust will inevitably repeat.

Conclusion

Narrator: The single most important takeaway from You Weren’t Supposed To See That is that the financial world is not operating on the principles found in textbooks. It is a dynamic, often irrational arena shaped by deep structural changes and raw human emotion. The market is driven less by calculated greed and more by a primal fear of being rendered obsolete. Economic policy is not always about prosperity, but sometimes about restoring a social order that benefits a select few. And our faith is quietly migrating from traditional institutions to the new "American Gods" of technology, whose power and influence now rival that of nations.

Brown's work challenges us to look beyond the daily fluctuations of the market and recognize the powerful, often hidden, currents moving beneath the surface. The most unsettling idea he presents is that what we perceive as the neutral mechanics of the economy are often instruments of social control. The final question the book leaves us with is a profound one: now that you have seen what you weren't supposed to, what will you do with that knowledge?

00:00/00:00