Aibrary Logo
Podcast thumbnail

The Curious History of Dating

9 min

Introduction

Narrator: Imagine a young Victorian lady, her heart fluttering, as she receives a small, fragrant bouquet of flowers—a tussie-mussie. Each bloom is a word in a secret, coded message of affection, a delicate dance of courtship in an era of suffocating social rules. Now, picture a person today, swiping through hundreds of faces on a smartphone, making a split-second judgment based on a few photos and a witty bio. The gulf between these two worlds seems immense, yet both individuals are driven by the same timeless human pursuit: the search for connection and love. How did we travel from coded flowers to casual swipes?

This dramatic evolution of romance, intimacy, and social ritual is the subject of Nichi Hodgson’s fascinating book, The Curious History of Dating. It takes readers on a journey through the centuries, revealing how the quest for a partner has been shaped by everything from economic necessity and technological innovation to war and moral panic.

The Marriage Market: When Love Was a Business

Key Insight 1

Narrator: In the 18th and early 19th centuries, courtship was less about romance and more about economics. For the upper classes, marriage was a strategic transaction designed to secure status and transfer wealth. The London "season" was the ultimate marketplace, where wealthy families paraded their daughters at exclusive balls and events, hoping to land a rich husband. The most exclusive of these venues was Almack's Assembly Rooms, a so-called "Marriage Mart" run by a committee of powerful noblewomen. The rules were so rigid that they famously denied entry to the Duke of Wellington, the hero of Waterloo, simply because he arrived wearing trousers instead of the required knee-breeches. This incident perfectly illustrates the era's obsession with social protocol, where even a national hero was subject to the strict regulations of the courtship game. For women, reputation was everything, and interactions were policed by chaperones, formal introductions, and a complex etiquette that made any unsupervised moment a potential scandal.

The Secret Language of Courtship

Key Insight 2

Narrator: Within these highly constrained social systems, the human need for emotional expression found clever and subtle outlets. While direct communication was forbidden in the early stages of courtship, lovers developed secret languages to convey their feelings. The most charming example of this was the "tussie-mussie," a small, fragrant bouquet where each flower held a specific meaning. A suitor could send a message of love with roses or of thoughtful admiration with pansies, and a lady could respond in kind, all under the guise of a simple gift. This allowed for a nuanced exchange of emotions that circumvented the era's rigid social rules. However, for those outside the elite circles or for individuals seeking connections beyond the ballroom, the options were riskier. The emergence of "Lonely Hearts" ads in newspapers offered a new, more direct path, but it was one fraught with danger. The infamous Red Barn Murder of 1827, where a young woman named Maria Marten was killed by a man she met through such an ad, became a sensational cautionary tale, underscoring the vulnerability of those who dared to step outside the prescribed methods of finding a partner.

The Great Disruption: How War and Wheels Unleashed Women

Key Insight 3

Narrator: The late Victorian era and the First World War acted as powerful catalysts, shattering old certainties and dramatically altering the landscape of dating. The invention of the bicycle gave women a revolutionary tool for independence. Suddenly, the "New Woman" could escape the watchful eye of her chaperone, venturing out alone to meet friends and potential suitors. This newfound mobility was so transformative that social reformer Susan B. Anthony declared in 1896 that the bicycle had "done more to emancipate women than anything else in the world." This freedom was amplified by the seismic social shifts of World War I. With men at the front, women entered the workforce in unprecedented numbers, gaining economic independence and a new sense of agency. The phenomenon of "khaki fever"—the intense attraction women felt for soldiers in uniform—led to a surge in whirlwind romances and hasty marriages, often conducted through letters. The war irrevocably changed gender dynamics, giving women a taste of freedom that could not be reversed.

The Roar of Revolution: From Petting Parties to The Pill

Key Insight 4

Narrator: The decades following the wars saw an acceleration of social change, culminating in the sexual revolution of the 1960s. The 1920s introduced the motorcar as a private space for courtship, while the 1950s saw the rise of "going steady" and dating for pleasure rather than purely for marriage. This shift was fueled by pioneering figures like Marie Stopes, whose clinics provided birth control to working-class women, and by groundbreaking research like the Kinsey Reports, which brought discussions of sex into the open. The 1960s blew the doors off completely. The widespread availability of the contraceptive pill separated sex from procreation for the first time on a mass scale. Publications like Helen Gurley Brown's Sex and the Single Girl urged women to embrace their sexuality, famously advising them to "reconsider the idea that sex without marriage is dirty." However, this new freedom was complex. For some, like the singer Marianne Faithfull, the partner-swapping culture of the era felt exploitative. She later reflected on her time with the Rolling Stones, stating, "I don’t like men them very much. They’re there to be used." Her experience reveals the darker side of the revolution, where old power imbalances often persisted under a new veneer of liberation.

The Digital Heart: From Computer Punch Cards to Swiping Right

Key Insight 5

Narrator: The final and most dramatic transformation in the history of dating has been driven by technology. The seeds were sown as early as 1959 with "Operation Match," a project by Stanford students who used an IBM computer to match couples based on a questionnaire. By the 1970s, commercial services like Dateline were popular, though they were plagued by the same issues seen today: dishonest profiles and unrealistic expectations. The rise of the internet in the 1990s brought "modem love," with chat rooms and early dating sites creating new virtual spaces for connection. This also introduced new forms of conflict, as seen in the story of Amy Taylor and David Pollard, who divorced after the husband's virtual affair in the online world of Second Life blurred the lines between fantasy and reality. Today, dating apps like Tinder have completely reshaped the landscape. Tinder's co-founder, Sean Rad, admitted, "We always saw Tinder, the interface, as a game." This gamification has introduced the "Choice Effect," where an endless supply of potential partners can lead to superficiality and an inability to commit, leaving many to wonder if technology has truly made finding love any easier.

Conclusion

Narrator: The single most important takeaway from The Curious History of Dating is that while the tools, rules, and technologies of courtship have been radically transformed, the core human desires for love, intimacy, and validation have remained remarkably constant. From the chaperoned balls of the 18th century to the algorithm-driven apps of the 21st, the fundamental goal has always been to find a meaningful connection in a world of ever-changing social pressures.

Ultimately, the book challenges us to reflect on our own dating lives. By understanding the historical weight behind our modern rituals—the pressure to create a perfect profile, the anxiety of the first message, the paralysis of infinite choice—we can see that we are not the first generation to struggle with the complexities of love. The question Hodgson leaves us with is a powerful one: Have we truly become freer, or have we simply traded the rigid rules of the past for a new, and perhaps equally demanding, set of digital-age anxieties?

00:00/00:00