Aibrary Logo
Podcast thumbnail

The Choice

9 min

Embrace the Possible

Introduction

Narrator: In the barren, smoke-filled barracks of Auschwitz, a notorious SS officer known as the "Angel of Death" arrives, looking for entertainment. The inmates, shorn and stripped of their identities, push a terrified sixteen-year-old girl forward. They tell the officer, Dr. Josef Mengele, that she is a dancer. He orders her to perform. With an orchestra playing "The Blue Danube," the young girl closes her eyes, not to the horror around her, but to the world within her. She imagines herself on the stage of the Budapest Opera House, dancing not for a killer, but for her life. This single, defiant act of inner freedom in the face of ultimate evil forms the crucible of Dr. Edith Eger's life and the core of her profound book, The Choice: Embrace the Possible. It is a memoir and a guide that explores how the human spirit can find liberation, not by escaping suffering, but by choosing how to respond to it.

Victimhood is a Choice, Not a Condition

Key Insight 1

Narrator: Dr. Eger makes a critical distinction between victimization and victimhood. Victimization is what is done to a person—an external event that is often out of their control. Victimhood, however, is an internal state, a story one tells oneself. It is the choice to remain defined by suffering. In her clinical practice, Dr. Eger observed that this choice is universal and has no hierarchy.

She recounts treating two mothers in back-to-back sessions. The first mother was consumed with grief and anger because her daughter was dying of a terminal illness. The second mother was distraught because her new Cadillac had been delivered in the wrong shade of yellow. On the surface, their problems seem worlds apart. Yet, Dr. Eger recognized that both women were in pain, both were struggling with unmet expectations and a lack of control. The woman with the Cadillac was not just upset about a car; she was expressing a deeper pain from a lonely marriage and unfulfilled dreams. Dr. Eger understood that while suffering is universal, staying stuck in the mindset of a victim is optional. The key question for anyone who has suffered is not "Why me?" but rather, "What now?" This shift in focus is the first step toward reclaiming one's power and choosing freedom over the prison of victimhood.

Inner Freedom Cannot Be Taken

Key Insight 2

Narrator: The most powerful lesson from Dr. Eger’s experience in the concentration camps is that while her captors could control her body, they could not touch her mind. This was a lesson her own mother imparted to her on the cattle car to Auschwitz, saying, "Just remember, no one can take away from you what you’ve put in your own mind."

This principle was tested in the most extreme way when Dr. Mengele ordered her to dance. Terrified, she drew on her mother’s words and her ballet master’s advice that her ecstasy would have to come from the inside. As the music played, she transported herself mentally to the Budapest Opera House, performing Tchaikovsky's Romeo and Juliet. In that moment, she was not a prisoner; she was a performer. She even found a moment of pity for her captor, realizing that he was the true prisoner, forever trapped by his own horrific actions. When she finished, Mengele tossed her a loaf of bread, which she shared with her bunkmates, saving their lives. This experience proved that even in a place designed for total dehumanization, one’s inner world remains a sanctuary of freedom and a powerful tool for survival.

Survival is an Act of Defiance and Connection

Key Insight 3

Narrator: In Auschwitz, survival was not merely a passive state of endurance; it was an active, often defiant, process. Dr. Eger learned that survival depended on small acts of resistance and, most importantly, on human connection. The rule was to transcend one's own needs and commit to something or someone outside oneself. For Edith, that commitment was to her sister, Magda.

This bond was tested during a selection process. An SS officer shoved Edith into a line that other inmates whispered was the "death line," separating her from Magda. In a moment of pure, impulsive courage, Edith caught a guard's eye and began performing a series of perfect cartwheels. The guard, momentarily distracted and amused, allowed Magda to run across the yard and join her sister. This daring act was not just for herself; it was an act of connection, a refusal to be separated from the one person who gave her a reason to live. It demonstrated that in the face of overwhelming power, small, creative acts of defiance, fueled by love, could change one's fate.

Healing Requires Confronting the Past

Key Insight 4

Narrator: After liberation, Dr. Eger, like many survivors, tried to build a new life by suppressing her past. She immigrated to America, worked in factories, and tried to assimilate, believing that the more securely she locked her memories away, the safer she would be. She lived by the mantra, "I had my secret, and my secret had me." However, this suppression only created a different kind of prison, one of anxiety and flashbacks.

Her true healing began only when she chose to confront her history. Decades later, as a successful psychologist, she accepted an invitation to speak in Berchtesgaden, Germany—Hitler's former mountain retreat. Staying in a hotel once reserved for the Nazi high command, she felt the full weight of her past. But instead of running, she walked to the ruins of Hitler's home. There, she performed a symbolic dance, not of rage, but of forgiveness. She forgave Hitler, not to absolve him, but to free herself from the hold he still had on her. More importantly, she began the process of forgiving herself for the irrational guilt she carried over her mother's death. This journey taught her that freedom is not about forgetting; it is about facing the darkness and choosing to no longer be its prisoner.

The Ultimate Question is 'What Now?'

Key Insight 5

Narrator: Dr. Eger’s personal journey of healing directly informed her professional work. She came to believe that the mindset of a survivor is defined by a single, forward-looking question: "What now?" This philosophy is powerfully illustrated in her work with a patient named Captain Jason Fuller, an Army captain who arrived at her office in a catatonic state, frozen by an unknown trauma.

Instead of trying to force him to talk about the past, Dr. Eger recognized he was stuck. She broke through his paralysis with an unexpected command: "You're going to take my dog for a walk." The simple, present-focused action jarred him out of his frozen state and created an opening for therapy. This approach encapsulates her core belief that while we cannot change the past, we can always choose our next step. By shifting the focus from the "why" of past suffering to the "what now" of present action, she helps her patients—and her readers—understand that they have the power to move from a state of helplessness to one of active, conscious choice.

Conclusion

Narrator: The single most important takeaway from The Choice is that true freedom is an inside job. It is not something granted by external circumstances, but something cultivated within. Dr. Edith Eger’s life is a testament to the fact that while we cannot always choose what happens to us, we always retain the ultimate human freedom: the power to choose our attitude, our response, and our own way forward.

The book leaves us with a profound challenge. It asks us to examine the prisons we build for ourselves—the resentments we hold, the grief we don't process, and the victim narratives we cling to. Dr. Eger's story is not just about surviving the unimaginable; it's about what it takes to truly live. It forces us to ask: What are the "secrets" that have a hold on us, and what single choice can we make today to begin our own liberation?

00:00/00:00