Aibrary Logo
Podcast thumbnail

Say What You Mean

9 min

A Mindful Approach to Nonviolent Communication

Introduction

Narrator: Imagine you’re at a farewell party for your partner. It’s a meaningful moment, a celebration of a year of hard work with people who have become like family. But in the back of your mind, a clock is ticking. You have an appointment to get a new car radio installed, a small detail in your grand plan to create the "perfect" road trip that starts tomorrow. As the party continues without a formal send-off, your anxiety grows. You nudge your partner, insisting it’s time to go. Reluctantly, they agree. In the car, the tears begin. You didn't just cut the party short; you cut a deeply meaningful experience short. In your fixation on the future, you completely missed the present. This very scenario, a painful lesson for author Oren Jay Sofer, lies at the heart of his book, Say What You Mean: A Mindful Approach to Nonviolent Communication. It reveals a fundamental truth: our ability to communicate effectively, to connect, and to love, hinges not on having the right words, but on our ability to be truly present.

Presence is the Unspoken Foundation of Connection

Key Insight 1

Narrator: Sofer argues that the first and most crucial step in mindful communication is to "lead with presence." This isn't just about paying attention; it's an embodied awareness of the present moment. Without it, we operate on autopilot, reacting from old habits and anxieties rather than responding with wisdom and care. The author learned this the hard way during the farewell party for his girlfriend, Evan. His intention was to create a perfect trip, but his lack of presence—his mind being consumed by the car radio appointment—led him to bulldoze Evan's feelings. He missed the fact that she was already having a wonderful, meaningful experience.

The book illustrates that presence is a skill that can be trained. Sofer describes a simple but profound exercise he uses in workshops. He has participants pair up and share a story. After a minute, he rings a bell, and they must pause mid-sentence. Almost universally, people report two things: how quickly they lost touch with their body and how internally stirred up they felt when they paused. This reveals how our minds are constantly pulled into the narrative, losing connection with the physical, present reality. By practicing anchoring our attention in bodily sensations—like the feeling of our feet on the floor or the rhythm of our breath—we can build the capacity to stay grounded, even in difficult conversations. This presence is what allows us to notice when we’re getting hooked by our own agenda, giving us the choice to return to the person in front of us.

Intention is the Invisible Force that Shapes Dialogue

Key Insight 2

Narrator: Once we establish presence, the next step is to engage from a place of "curiosity and care." Sofer emphasizes that our intention—the inner motivation behind our words—is often more powerful than the words themselves. People can feel where we’re coming from, whether it’s a genuine desire to understand or a hidden agenda to blame, control, or prove a point. Without a conscious intention, we default to what Sofer calls "the blame game," a tragic and backward strategy for inspiring change where we focus on what’s wrong with others or ourselves.

To show the radical power of a different intention, the book points to the incredible story of Daryl Davis, an African American musician. From a young age, Davis was haunted by a simple question: "How can you hate me when you don't even know me?" This question, born of pure curiosity, led him on a journey to meet and talk with members of the Ku Klux Klan. He didn't approach them with anger or a desire to change them. His intention was simply to understand. He sat with them, listened to their views, and treated them with respect. Over time, this genuine human connection began to dissolve their hatred. Many of these men, who had dedicated their lives to an ideology of hate, ended up leaving the Klan and giving Davis their robes and hoods. Davis’s story is an extreme example of a core principle: an intention rooted in curiosity and care can create openings for connection and transformation where blame and confrontation would only build higher walls.

Conflict Lives in Strategies, Not in Needs

Key Insight 3

Narrator: The third step, "focusing on what matters," requires us to train our attention. Sofer, drawing on the work of Nonviolent Communication (NVC), argues that what truly matters are universal human needs—core values like safety, respect, connection, and autonomy. He makes a critical distinction between our needs and our strategies, which are the specific actions we take to meet those needs. Conflict, he explains, almost always occurs at the level of strategies, not needs.

The book provides the example of Kristin, a woman in a recurring conflict with her mother. Her mother frequently corrected her parenting style in front of her young son, leading to screaming matches. Kristin’s strategy was to argue and defend her parenting beliefs. Her mother’s strategy was to intervene directly. Both strategies were failing. When Kristin shifted her focus to the underlying needs, everything changed. She realized her need was for respect and support in her parenting. She then considered her mother’s needs and surmised that her mother was trying to meet a need for contribution and to care for her grandson’s well-being.

Suddenly, the conflict was no longer about who was right or wrong. It was about finding a new strategy that could honor everyone’s needs. Kristin could now have a conversation about her need for respect, while also acknowledging her mother’s need to contribute. This shift from a battle of strategies to a collaborative exploration of needs opens up creative possibilities that were previously invisible.

A True Request is a Gift, Not a Demand

Key Insight 4

Narrator: Bringing all these principles together culminates in the art of making requests. Sofer explains that many of us are conditioned to avoid asking for what we want, fearing we’ll be a burden. Yet, a request is not a sign of weakness; it’s an acknowledgment of our interdependence and an invitation for connection. The key difference between a request and a demand lies in how we react when we hear "no." If we can meet a "no" with curiosity about the other person's needs, it was a true request. If we react with anger or guilt, it was a demand in disguise.

Sofer tells a powerful story about a female NVC practitioner who woke in the middle of the night to find a strange man in her bedroom. Instead of reacting with fear and aggression, she focused on connection. She asked him what time it was and how he got in. She learned he had nowhere to go. Seeing his humanity and his need for shelter, she made an incredible request that also served as an offer: she offered him the guest bedroom for the night. He accepted, slept there, and left in the morning. Her ability to see past the threatening strategy (breaking into a house) to the underlying need (shelter) and make a request that accounted for both of their needs for safety and care de-escalated a dangerous situation. This illustrates that a well-formed request, rooted in presence and care, is one of the most powerful tools we have to navigate the world and get our needs met in a way that honors everyone.

Conclusion

Narrator: The single most important takeaway from Say What You Mean is that effective communication is not a set of techniques to be deployed, but an internal orientation. It’s not about what we say, but, as the author puts it, "where we’re coming from." The three steps—leading with presence, coming from curiosity and care, and focusing on what matters—are not a formula but a practice in cultivating an inner state from which connection can naturally arise.

The book leaves us with a profound challenge. It asks us to take radical responsibility for our inner world—our reactivity, our intentions, and our focus—as the primary path to transforming our outer world. So, the next time you find yourself in a difficult conversation, before you search for the right words to say, can you first pause and ask yourself: Where am I coming from right now?

00:00/00:00