
The Goal-Setting Trap
10 min100 Reflections on Positive Psychology
Golden Hook & Introduction
SECTION
Michelle: Most goal-setting advice is wrong. It tells you to be realistic, to focus on the practical steps, to make a sensible plan. But what if that very 'realism' is the thing that guarantees you'll end up with a life or a business you don't actually want? Mark: Whoa, that's a bold start. You’re basically saying my beloved to-do lists and five-year plans might be leading me astray. I feel personally attacked, Michelle. But I'm also intrigued. Where is this delightful chaos coming from? Michelle: It’s a provocative idea at the heart of a reflection in the book Pursuing the Good Life by Christopher Peterson. And it’s one of those insights that, once you hear it, you start seeing it everywhere. Mark: Christopher Peterson... that name rings a bell. He's a big deal in psychology, right? Not just some airport bookstore guru? Michelle: A huge deal. He was one of the key founders of the entire field of positive psychology, alongside Martin Seligman. He was a celebrated professor at the University of Michigan. And what's fantastic about this book is that it’s not some dense, impenetrable academic text. It’s a collection of 100 short reflections, many from his popular blog. He was an award-winning teacher known for making complex science feel human and useful. Mark: I like that. Science that you can actually use. The book itself is well-regarded, isn't it? I remember hearing it praised for being practical and witty, which is a rare combo for an academic. Michelle: Exactly. It’s praised for its warmth and wisdom. And he tells this one fantastic story that perfectly illustrates this dangerous confusion between our goals and our plans to get there. He frames it with a simple, powerful phrase he learned from a business workshop: "Distinguish the ends from the means."
The Vision Trap: Why We Confuse 'How' with 'What'
SECTION
Mark: Distinguish the ends from the means. Okay, my brain immediately wants to file that under ‘obvious business jargon.’ But the way you set it up, it feels like there’s a trap hidden in there. Michelle: There is. And you’ve probably fallen into it a dozen times this month. We all do. It’s the tendency to get so focused on the how that we completely forget to define the what. Mark: Oh, I do this all the time. It’s like I decide I want to go on a vacation. The first thing I do is open a browser and search for cheap flights. And suddenly, my entire vacation, the 'end' I wanted, is being dictated by a $200 round-trip ticket to a city I have zero emotional investment in. The 'means'—the cheap flight—just hijacked my actual goal. Michelle: That is the perfect analogy. You let the tool define the project. You wanted rest and adventure, and you ended up with a budget weekend in a place you didn't even want to go to, all because the means were easy and available. Peterson argues this happens with the most important decisions in our lives. Mark: Like our careers. You take the job that offers a clear promotion ladder, the 'means', without asking if that ladder is leaning against the right wall, if the 'end' is a life you actually want. Michelle: Precisely. And this is where the story he tells comes in. It’s about a small business that faced this exact dilemma on a massive scale. It’s the story of Zingerman's Delicatessen in Ann Arbor, Michigan. Mark: I think I’ve heard of them. Aren't they famous for their sandwiches or something? A local legend? Michelle: They are a beloved institution. Known for incredible food, fanatical customer service, and a deep connection to their community. By the 1990s, they were so successful that the inevitable business question came knocking. Mark: Let me guess: expansion. Franchising. A Zingerman's in every airport and suburban strip mall. Michelle: Exactly. The offers were pouring in. It was the classic American business dream. The 'means' for massive growth and wealth were being handed to them on a silver platter. This was their cheap flight to Cleveland moment, but on a multi-million dollar scale. Mark: Hold on. For most businesses, that isn't a dilemma; that's the jackpot. That's the goal. You build a successful brand, and then you scale it. Why would you even hesitate? It almost sounds like business malpractice to turn that down. Michelle: Because the co-founder, Ari Weinzweig, and his partner, Paul Saginaw, did something radical. Before they looked at the means—the franchise offers—they stopped and focused entirely on the end. They asked themselves, "What do we want Zingerman's to be in the year 2020?" Not how much money they wanted to make. What they wanted it to feel like. Mark: That’s a very different question. That’s not a spreadsheet question; that’s a philosophical one. Michelle: It is. And they sat down and wrote out their vision. They envisioned a community of unique, high-quality Zingerman's businesses, all located in and around Ann Arbor. They envisioned a place where staff could grow and become partners. They envisioned a business that was a vibrant, integral part of its local community. A place that was, in their words, "great, not gigantic." Mark: And a national franchise chain of delis... Michelle: ...was the polar opposite of that vision. The means, franchising, would have actively destroyed the end they had just defined. It would have meant standardized menus, less control over quality, and a disconnection from the very community that made them special. They would have gotten rich, but they would have killed the soul of the thing they built. Mark: Wow. So they saw the cheap flight for what it was. A distraction. A trap that would take them somewhere they didn't want to go. That takes an incredible amount of clarity and courage. Michelle: It’s the core of the lesson. They had the discipline to define the destination first. Once the vision was crystal clear, the decision was obvious. They turned down the franchise money.
The Zingerman's Way: A Blueprint for 'Great, Not Gigantic'
SECTION
Mark: Okay, that’s an amazing story of integrity. But my practical, skeptical side is kicking in. A vision is nice, but you have to pay the bills. How did they grow? How did they create opportunities for their staff if they weren't going to build a hundred stores across the country? What were the new means they created to serve that vision? Michelle: That’s the most brilliant part of the story. Rejecting the easy means forced them to become more creative. It unlocked a completely different, and arguably better, path. They created what they call the "Zingerman's Community of Businesses." Mark: What does that even mean? It sounds a bit corporate and vague. Michelle: It's actually very concrete. Instead of stamping out copies of the deli, they started new, unique businesses that shared the Zingerman's philosophy of quality and service. They opened a bakery to supply the deli with world-class bread. Then they opened a creamery to make artisanal cheese and gelato. Then a coffee company, a mail-order business, a restaurant, and even a business that makes candy bars. Mark: Wait, so they're all different businesses, but under one umbrella? Michelle: Yes. Each is a distinct entity with its own partners, many of whom are former Zingerman's employees who worked their way up. But they all share the same commitment to the original vision. They are a collection of great, local businesses, not one gigantic, diluted chain. Mark: I get it now. It’s like they had a blueprint for a beautiful, unique, handcrafted neighborhood. Franchising would have been like dropping a generic, pre-fabricated McMansion in the middle of it. It would have made money, but it would have ruined the entire aesthetic, the whole point of the neighborhood. Michelle: That's a perfect analogy. And to help build that neighborhood, they created another business: ZingTrain. It’s a training company where they teach other businesses—from hospitals to tech startups to libraries—the principles of customer service, open-book management, and visioning that made them successful. Mark: That is genius. They monetized their philosophy. They found a new 'means' that was perfectly aligned with their 'end'. They get to spread their ideas without compromising their core identity. Michelle: Exactly. And Peterson’s profound point in the book is that this isn't just a cute business story. It’s a model for life. We are all constantly presented with 'franchise opportunities'—the safe career path, the conventional life script, the relationship that looks good on paper. The means are clear, socially approved, and often lucrative. Mark: But we rarely stop to do the hard work of writing the vision. Of asking what a 'great' life, not just a 'successful' one, looks like for us. We just take the promotion, buy the house in the suburbs, and follow the script. Michelle: And we can wake up at 45, successful by every external metric, but feeling hollowed out, because the means we chose so carefully led us to an end we never consciously wanted. We built a fantastic ladder, climbed it perfectly, and only then realized it was against the wrong building. Zingerman's had the wisdom to check the address before they started climbing.
Synthesis & Takeaways
SECTION
Mark: This is so much bigger than a sandwich shop. It's a fundamental re-framing of how to approach... well, everything. So, what's the one thing we should really take away from this? Is it just 'have a vision'? Because that can feel a bit fluffy. Michelle: I think it’s more specific and more powerful than that. The takeaway is: Fall in love with your vision, not your plan. Be fiercely committed to the end, but completely flexible about the means. Mark: I like that. Your plan is just a hypothesis. It’s a tool. It’s not sacred. The vision is the sacred thing. Michelle: Precisely. The plan, the means, can and should change as you learn more, as the world changes. But the vision—that clear, specific, emotionally compelling picture of what 'great' looks and feels like for you—that's the anchor. That's your north star. Zingerman's didn't succeed despite turning down the easy money; they succeeded because of it. Their unwavering commitment to their end goal forced them to invent a more creative, more resilient, and ultimately, more fulfilling path. Mark: It’s a powerful reminder that the most creative work often happens within constraints. By saying 'no' to the obvious path, they had to say 'yes' to a much more interesting one. Michelle: And that’s the challenge for all of us. The book is called Pursuing the Good Life, and this is a core component. The good life isn't found by accident, and it's not found by just following the most convenient path. It's designed. Mark: So the challenge for everyone listening is simple, but definitely not easy: Before you make your next big plan, for your career, for your family, for your health—stop. Take thirty minutes. And actually write down, in one paragraph, what the perfect outcome looks and feels like. Forget the 'how' for a minute. Just get crystal clear on the 'what'. Michelle: A perfect place to start. It might be the most productive thirty minutes you spend all year. Mark: A powerful and practical thought from a book that sounds full of them. Michelle: It truly is. A wonderful guide to a life of flourishing. Mark: This is Aibrary, signing off.