
Exactly What to Say
10 minThe Magic Words for Influence and Impact
Introduction
Narrator: Imagine a salesperson who has just delivered a flawless presentation. The potential client is nodding along, clearly impressed. But when the time comes to close the deal, the conversation stalls. An awkward silence hangs in the air. The client says, "I need some time to think about it," and the opportunity evaporates. What went wrong? In another scenario, a manager tries to introduce an innovative new strategy to their team, but is met with immediate resistance and skepticism. The idea is dead on arrival.
These moments of failure often come down to a single, critical factor: not knowing what to say. In his book, Exactly What to Say: The Magic Words for Influence and Impact, author Phil M. Jones argues that success in these pivotal conversations isn't about luck or charisma, but about using specific, tested phrases that speak directly to the subconscious brain. He provides a playbook of these "Magic Words," designed to bypass over-analysis, overcome objections, and guide people toward making decisions.
Opening the Conversation Without Pressure
Key Insight 1
Narrator: The fear of rejection often prevents people from sharing their best ideas or making a sale. To overcome this, Jones introduces phrases designed to open a conversation in a rejection-free way. The first is, "I'm not sure if it's for you, but..." This phrase works by immediately lowering the listener's guard. The first part, "I'm not sure if it's for you," signals that there is no pressure, which piques curiosity. The word "but" then acts as a pivot, negating the uncertainty and highlighting the potential value of what comes next. The subconscious message the listener hears is, "You might want to look at this."
For example, a sales representative at a tech conference, Sarah, was struggling to engage clients who were wary of sales pitches. Instead of a direct approach, she began saying, "I'm not sure if it's for you, but would you happen to know someone interested in streamlining their project management?" This non-threatening opener intrigued listeners, leading to more productive conversations and potential sales.
A similar technique is to ask, "How open-minded are you?" Most people want to see themselves as open-minded, so the question primes them to be receptive. When a marketing manager needed to convince her skeptical team to try an unconventional new strategy, she didn't start by listing its benefits. Instead, she opened the meeting by asking, "How open-minded are you about exploring new avenues for client engagement?" This framed the discussion in a way that made it difficult for the team to refuse consideration without appearing closed-minded. They agreed to a trial, which ultimately proved highly successful.
Creating Motivation Through Future-Pacing
Key Insight 2
Narrator: Jones emphasizes that decisions are made emotionally before they are justified logically. To influence someone, you must give them an emotional reason to move. He explains that people are primarily motivated by two things: moving toward a potential gain or moving away from a potential loss, with loss aversion being the more powerful driver. The key is to create a strong contrast between their current reality and a possible future.
Two phrases are particularly effective for this. The first is, "How would you feel if...?" This question prompts a person to emotionally experience a future scenario. A financial advisor could ask, "How would you feel if this time next year you were debt-free, living in your dream home?" This creates a powerful, positive emotional state that motivates action. Conversely, asking, "How would you feel if your competition passed you?" triggers the fear of loss, motivating a business owner to take preventative measures.
The second phrase, "Just imagine," works in a similar way by activating the brain's visual center. A manager motivating a team member might say, "Just imagine the smiles on your kids' faces when you tell them you've booked a trip to Disneyland." This allows the employee's own mind to build a vivid, personal, and compelling case for hitting their sales targets, a reality far more powerful than any the manager could describe.
Regaining Control and Handling Objections
Key Insight 3
Narrator: In any negotiation, the person asking the questions is the one in control. When someone raises an objection, they are taking control of the conversation. To handle this, Jones advises against arguing and instead recommends using questions to regain control and uncover the real issue.
When faced with someone who thinks they know best, the phrase "What do you know about...?" can gently shift their certainty to doubt. For instance, if a client dismisses a new software solution, a salesperson could ask, "What do you know about the latest advancements in AI-driven automation that could streamline your processes?" This prompts the person to explain their knowledge, often revealing it to be incomplete or outdated, and making them more receptive to new information.
For more direct objections like "I can't afford it" or "I don't have the time," the go-to response is, "What makes you say that?" This simple, non-confrontational question forces the other person to look inward and explain the real reason behind their statement. It turns an objection into a discovery process, giving you the information needed to truly help them or understand why they cannot proceed.
Making Decisions Easy
Key Insight 4
Narrator: Indecision is one of the biggest obstacles to progress. To help people make a choice, Jones suggests simplifying their options. One powerful method is to present "three options." People prefer to feel they are making their own choice, and limiting the field to three makes the decision manageable. The technique involves framing two of the options as clearly less desirable, making your preferred choice the obvious and easiest path. For example, when recruiting a new business partner who is hesitant to leave their current job, one might present three options: 1) Go through the difficult process of finding another job, 2) Do nothing and remain unhappy, or 3) Try this new opportunity on the side. Then, by asking, "Of those three options, what’s going to be easier for you?" the third option becomes the path of least resistance.
An even more direct method is to frame the choice by stating, "There are two types of people in this world..." This creates a polarizing choice that prompts an instant decision. For example, one could say, "There are two types of people: those who passively rely on their employers for financial security, and those who take control of their own financial future." This forces the listener to identify with the more desirable group, stacking the odds in favor of the decision you want them to make.
Securing Commitment and Follow-Through
Key Insight 5
Narrator: Once a conversation is nearing its end, it's crucial to guide it to a clear conclusion. Many discussions fail because no one takes the lead. Jones recommends using the phrase, "What happens next is..." to clearly and confidently outline the next steps. This removes ambiguity and tells the other person exactly what to do to move forward. For instance, a salesperson might say, "What happens next is we'll take a few minutes to register your details, and then we'll schedule a kick-off call for next week. In terms of your details, what's the best address for you?" The final, easy-to-answer question makes it simple for them to give the first "yes."
If you've asked someone to do something and need to follow up, the fear of hearing "no" can be paralyzing. To disarm this, Jones suggests opening with, "I'm guessing you haven't got around to..." By preemptively stating the negative scenario, you remove their ability to use it as an excuse. They are then prompted to either correct you with the positive news that they have, in fact, completed the task, or to commit to fixing the situation immediately.
Conclusion
Narrator: The single most important takeaway from Exactly What to Say is that subtle, deliberate changes in language can yield dramatic results. The power lies not in manipulation, but in understanding human psychology and making it easier for people to say "yes." The book's "Magic Words" are tools that bypass conscious resistance and speak to the part of the brain that makes quick, intuitive decisions.
Perhaps the most challenging and insightful idea is captured in a story about a successful telecommunications salesperson named Roger. When customers asked him how the complex new digital technology worked, he stopped trying to impress them with technical details. Instead, he found his greatest success by simply smiling and saying, "It works great." This illustrates the book's core philosophy: your goal is not to prove how much you know, but to instill confidence and make the other person feel good about their decision. The ultimate challenge, then, is to shift your focus from delivering information to delivering impact, one magic word at a time.