
Altered Traits
11 minScience Reveals How Meditation Changes Your Mind, Brain, and Body
Introduction
Narrator: In the mid-1970s, two young Harvard researchers, Daniel Goleman and Richard Davidson, arranged to test a meditation teacher from Asia who called himself Swami X. He claimed to possess extraordinary yogic powers, including the ability to control his own blood pressure at will. In the lab, however, with sensors attached, Swami X failed completely. He couldn't influence his blood pressure at all, blaming the "toxic tea" he'd been served for sabotaging his gifts. It was later revealed that he was a former shoe factory manager who had abandoned his family to reinvent himself as a guru. This encounter became a cautionary tale for the researchers, highlighting a field rife with both profound potential and charismatic hucksterism. How could one separate the genuine, lasting benefits of meditation from the hype and exaggerated claims?
This question is at the heart of Altered Traits: Science Reveals How Meditation Changes Your Mind, Brain, and Body. Authors Daniel Goleman and Richard J. Davidson, now world-renowned figures in psychology and neuroscience, combine their decades of research to provide a definitive, evidence-based answer. They argue that the true power of meditation lies not in creating temporary pleasant states, but in cultivating enduring, positive "altered traits" that can permanently reshape our minds and brains for the better.
Meditation Follows Two Distinct Paths
Key Insight 1
Narrator: The authors begin by clarifying that "meditation" is not a single activity but a vast landscape with two primary paths: the "wide" path and the "deep" path. The wide path is what most people in the West are familiar with. It involves pragmatic applications like mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) or the use of simple meditation apps. The goal here is often immediate relief from stress, anxiety, or pain.
A powerful example of this wide path is the story of Steve Z, a lieutenant colonel who was working in the Pentagon on September 11, 2001, when the hijacked plane crashed into the building. Buried in debris and suffering a concussion, he survived but was left with severe PTSD. He became hypervigilant, anxious in enclosed spaces, and irritable. A psychotherapist introduced him to mindfulness, which, as Steve described it, "gave me something I could do to help feel more calm, less stressed, not be so reactive." Consistent practice helped him manage his trauma, illustrating how the wide path offers practical tools for well-being.
The deep path, in contrast, is focused on profound and lasting transformations of being, rooted in ancient spiritual traditions. This is the path of yogis and dedicated monastics who spend tens of thousands of hours in practice. The authors argue that while the wide path is beneficial, the deep path is where we find evidence for true altered traits—fundamental, lasting changes to a person's baseline state of mind.
The Real Goal Is Altered Traits, Not Altered States
Key Insight 2
Narrator: A central argument of the book is the crucial distinction between temporary "altered states" and lasting "altered traits." An altered state is a transient experience, like the feeling of calm during a 20-minute meditation session or the blissful high one might feel on a retreat. An altered trait, however, is an enduring characteristic that persists long after the meditation session is over, fundamentally changing how a person experiences daily life.
Co-author Richie Davidson experienced this difference firsthand. As a graduate student, he attended an intensive ten-day Vipassana retreat in India. After days of painful sitting, he broke through into a state of total absorption and profound well-being. He felt transformed. Yet, on the long journey back to New York, beset by illness and the culture shock of returning home, the blissful state completely vanished. He was, as the authors bluntly put it, the "same schmuck" he was before.
This experience fueled his scientific curiosity: How do temporary states become lasting traits? The authors use a traditional story to illustrate this point. A yogi spends years in a cave achieving rarefied states of consciousness. Convinced of his enlightenment, he descends into a busy bazaar. When a young boy accidentally steps on his foot, the yogi flies into a rage, ready to strike the child. In that moment, he realizes his inner work is far from complete and returns to his cave. The high achieved in the cave was a state; equanimity in the chaos of the world is a trait.
A Calm Mind Can Be Trained
Key Insight 3
Narrator: One of the most well-researched benefits of meditation is its ability to reduce stress. The authors explain that modern life subjects us to chronic psychological stress, which keeps our body's threat-detection system—centered in a brain region called the amygdala—on a hair trigger. This can lead to chronic inflammation and a host of health problems.
The development of Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) by Jon Kabat-Zinn provides a powerful case study. In the 1970s, Kabat-Zinn, a molecular biologist and dedicated meditator, had a vision to adapt ancient mindfulness practices for patients with chronic pain and stress. He created an eight-week secular program that included body scans, mindful walking, and sitting meditation. The program was a success, not because it cured diseases, but because it changed patients' relationship to their pain and suffering.
Scientific studies have since validated this effect. Research by Philippe Goldin at Stanford showed that after an MBSR course, patients with social anxiety had lower amygdala activity when confronted with stressful thoughts. Their brains showed a stronger ability to regulate emotional reactions. This demonstrates that meditation can function as a kind of training for the mind, strengthening the neural circuits for emotional regulation and creating a more resilient, undisturbed mind.
Compassion Is a Skill, Not Just a Feeling
Key Insight 4
Narrator: While reducing stress is a key benefit, the authors argue that contemplative traditions place an even greater emphasis on cultivating positive qualities like compassion and loving-kindness. They distinguish between empathy—feeling with someone, which can lead to distress and burnout—and compassion, which is the warm, active wish for another to be free from suffering.
Research shows that compassion is a trainable skill that corresponds to distinct brain activity. When novice meditators are shown images of suffering, their brains react with empathy, which can be overwhelming. However, when advanced meditators like the Tibetan monk Mingyur Rinpoche engage in compassion meditation, their brains show a massive surge of activity—up to 800%—in circuits associated with love and positive feelings, not distress. This suggests they have trained their minds to respond to suffering with a readiness to help, rather than with personal anguish.
This training has tangible effects. One study found that even a brief, two-and-a-half-hour web-based course in loving-kindness meditation led participants to donate to charity at a higher rate than a control group. The authors posit that humans may have a "biological preparedness" for goodness, and that compassion meditation taps into and strengthens this innate capacity.
The Yogi's Brain Reveals the Potential for Enduring Transformation
Key Insight 5
Narrator: The most groundbreaking evidence for altered traits comes from studies of "Olympic-level" meditators—yogis with 12,000 to 62,000 hours of lifetime practice. After early failed attempts to study yogis in the Himalayas, the authors, with the help of monk and scientist Matthieu Ricard, were able to bring these adepts into their lab at the University of Wisconsin.
The results were astonishing. While analyzing the data, researcher Antoine Lutz stumbled upon a discovery. He found that the yogis' brains produced incredibly powerful and coherent electrical brainwaves known as gamma oscillations, not just during meditation, but in their baseline, resting state. The amplitude of these gamma waves was, on average, twenty-five times greater than that of the control group. This was the neural signature they had been looking for: evidence of a brain that had been permanently rewired by practice.
These yogis also demonstrated a remarkable "inverted V" response to pain. When anticipating a painful stimulus, their brains remained calm. During the pain, their sensory brain regions responded with high intensity, but they recovered almost instantly once it was over. This is an optimal emotional regulation strategy—fully present for an experience without the baggage of anxiety before or rumination after. These findings provide the strongest evidence that sustained, deep practice can produce truly altered traits, leading to a fundamental and lasting transformation of being.
Conclusion
Narrator: The core message of Altered Traits is that meditation is far more than a tool for temporary relaxation. It is a systematic method for mental training that, with consistent practice, can fundamentally reshape the brain and cultivate enduring positive qualities. The journey from a stressed-out beginner finding a moment of calm to a yogi whose very brainwaves reflect a state of spacious awareness is a long one, but the science now shows it is a real and achievable path.
The book challenges us to re-evaluate our approach to mental well-being. What if we treated mental fitness with the same dedication we apply to physical fitness? The evidence suggests that by intentionally training our minds, we can move beyond simply managing our stress and begin to cultivate the very best within ourselves—a mind that is not only calm and focused, but also primed for love and deep, abiding compassion.