Aibrary Logo
Podcast thumbnail

The Success Myth

10 min

Letting Go of Having It All

Introduction

Narrator: In 2018, author and podcaster Emma Gannon was on a flight to the Isle of Man to deliver a keynote speech. By all external measures, she was the picture of success—chauffeured to the airport, wearing new clothes, and professionally thriving. Yet, as the small plane hit severe turbulence, a wave of terror washed over her. The woman next to her, however, remained perfectly calm. She told Gannon that she was content, that she had achieved everything she wanted in life and was at peace. The contrast was jarring. Later that night, alone in a sterile hotel room after a successful speech, Gannon broke down, sobbing. She realized her identity had become a walking billboard for her achievements, and that this outward success had left her feeling hollow and disconnected. This profound disconnect between the appearance of success and the feeling of fulfillment is the central puzzle explored in her book, The Success Myth: Letting Go of Having It All.

The Success Formula Is a Lie

Key Insight 1

Narrator: The book begins by dismantling the foundational myth that there is a universal, one-size-fits-all formula for success. Society sells a seductive story: if you just work hard enough, follow the right steps, and tick the right boxes, you will achieve a happy, successful life. Gannon argues this is a dangerous fiction. The world isn't a level playing field, and factors like privilege, luck, and systemic inequality are often ignored in the triumphant narratives of "self-made" individuals.

This myth is particularly damaging because it fails to account for structural barriers. Gannon highlights this with the story of Terri White, the former editor-in-chief of Empire magazine. After having a child, White found it impossible to sustain her high-powered career. The inflexible hours, the high cost of childcare, and a workplace culture not designed for working mothers forced her to make a choice: her career or her family. She left her job, not because she lacked ambition or talent, but because the "formula" for success in her industry was inherently gendered and incompatible with motherhood. Her story reveals that the path to traditional success is often built on a masculine model of power and availability, penalizing those who cannot or will not conform. The success formula isn't just flawed; for many, it's a setup for failure.

The Unholy Trinity of Modern Work: Productivity, Identity, and Happiness

Key Insight 2

Narrator: Gannon argues that our modern work culture is built on a toxic trinity of interconnected myths: that we must be constantly productive, that our jobs define who we are, and that professional success will make us happy.

First is the Productivity Myth. In a world of endless to-do lists and performance metrics, rest is seen as weakness. Gannon illustrates this with the story of a lawyer she met at a wedding. He was so profoundly exhausted from working until the early hours every night that he could barely hold a conversation. His burnout was not a personal failing but a systemic expectation. This relentless pressure to perform leads to what journalist Anna Codrea-Rado calls "productivity dysmorphia," a state where, despite achieving a huge amount, you feel like you've done nothing at all.

This bleeds into the "You Are Your Job" Myth. Gannon shares a personal story of going for a massage and, when asked for her hobbies on the intake form, realizing with a shock that she had none. Her entire identity had been consumed by her work. This is a trap many fall into, especially in an era of "personal branding" where we are encouraged to monetize our personalities. When our job is our identity, any professional setback feels like a personal annihilation. As Gannon learned, your job will never truly love you back.

Finally, these two myths are propped up by the Happiness Myth—the idea that achieving professional success will grant lasting contentment. Through hundreds of interviews on her podcast, Gannon found the opposite to be true. Many outwardly successful people, from celebrities to CEOs, confessed to feeling insecure, anxious, and unfulfilled. The tragic story of former Miss USA Cheslie Kryst, who died by suicide despite a flourishing career, is a stark reminder that external accolades are no shield against inner turmoil. True well-being, Gannon argues, requires embracing the full spectrum of human emotions, not chasing a permanent state of happiness that success can never deliver.

The Empty Promises of Status and Wealth

Key Insight 3

Narrator: Two of the most powerful engines driving the success myth are the allure of fame and the promise of wealth. Gannon deconstructs both, revealing them as hollow idols. The Celebrity Myth suggests that fame is the ultimate validation, but the reality is often one of isolation and dehumanization. Gannon recounts observing an A-list actress at a book launch who couldn't interact normally with anyone; her fame created an invisible wall, turning her into an object of fascination rather than a person. This is echoed in the experience of footballer Alex Scott, who shared that despite her incredible career, she would often curl up at home and cry, feeling guilty for being sad when her life looked so perfect from the outside.

Similarly, the Money Myth equates financial abundance with happiness. While Gannon acknowledges that financial stability is crucial for well-being, the relentless pursuit of more wealth often leads to a dead end. She tells the story of a five-star family holiday she took as a teenager. The family was incredibly wealthy, but they were also deeply unhappy, with the father constantly berating his children and the mother retreating into silence. The luxury was a thin veneer over a foundation of misery. Research supports this, showing that emotional well-being tends to plateau after a certain income level. Beyond that point, more money doesn't equal more happiness. Instead, Gannon suggests we should value other currencies, like time, connection, and peace of mind, which are often sacrificed in the name of financial gain.

Redefining Ambition and Letting Go of the Finish Line

Key Insight 4

Narrator: In the final part of the book, Gannon encourages a radical re-evaluation of our life goals. This involves dismantling the "Tickbox Myth"—the idea that life is a checklist of milestones like marriage, homeownership, and children. These are not universal goals but social constructs, and chasing them without introspection can lead to a life that looks right but feels wrong. We are pressured to follow a linear path, but life is messy and cyclical.

This leads to a new understanding of ambition. The traditional, relentless climb is being replaced by a desire for something more sustainable. For many, this means redefining ambition not as a quest for more, but as a quest for "enough." It’s about finding contentment in the present rather than constantly striving. Quitting is reframed not as failure, but as an act of strength. The decision by gymnast Simone Biles to withdraw from the Tokyo Olympics to protect her mental health is a powerful example of this new form of ambition—one that prioritizes well-being over winning.

Ultimately, Gannon dismantles the "Arrival Myth"—the belief that once we achieve a certain goal, we will finally arrive at a state of lasting happiness. She shares her own anticlimactic feeling after publishing her first book, a lifelong dream that didn't magically solve her problems or change her life overnight. The truth, she concludes, is that there is no finish line. Success is not a destination.

Conclusion

Narrator: The single most important takeaway from The Success Myth is that the only definition of success that matters is your own. The book is a powerful permission slip to opt out of the frantic, anxiety-inducing race for external validation and to turn inward instead. It's a call to unlearn the scripts society has written for us and to have the courage to write our own.

Gannon leaves readers with a profound challenge: to stop living for the "when" and start appreciating the "now." The real work is not in achieving the next milestone, but in building a life that feels good on the inside, not one that just looks good on the outside. The most challenging question the book poses is also its most liberating: What would you do if you decided you have already arrived?

00:00/00:00