
The Post-Truth Business
11 minHow to Rebuild Brand Authenticity in a Distrusting World
Introduction
Narrator: Imagine a global brand spending millions on a high-profile ad. It features a beloved celebrity, Kendall Jenner, stepping away from a photoshoot to join a diverse, smiling protest. The tension is high until she hands a police officer a can of Pepsi, and the crowd erupts in cheers. Unity is achieved. The problem? The ad was released in 2017, a time of raw, real-world protests about social justice. The backlash was immediate and brutal. The campaign was accused of being tone-deaf, trivializing serious social movements, and cynically co-opting activism to sell soda. Pepsi pulled the ad within days, issuing a public apology. This spectacular failure wasn't just a marketing misstep; it was a symptom of a much larger problem. We now operate in a world where audiences are deeply skeptical, and the lines between truth, marketing, and manipulation have blurred into a landscape of profound distrust. In his book, The Post-Truth Business: How to Rebuild Brand Authenticity in a Distrusting World, author and brand strategist Sean Pillot de Chenecey provides a crucial field manual for navigating this treacherous new terrain, arguing that for businesses, authenticity is no longer a choice—it's the only path to survival.
The War on Truth Has Devalued Trust
Key Insight 1
Narrator: The book argues that the business world is grappling with a crisis born from a "post-truth" environment, a term Oxford Dictionaries defined as circumstances where "objective facts are less influential in shaping public opinion than appeals to emotion and personal belief." This isn't a new phenomenon. The author traces its roots back to the 1980s Iran-Contra scandal, when President Reagan admitted that while "the facts and the evidence" showed he traded arms for hostages, his "heart and best intentions" told him it wasn't true. The public, wanting to believe in their leader, largely accepted this emotional appeal over the factual reality.
Today, this dynamic is supercharged by social media. Platforms designed to give everyone a voice have also created echo chambers and accelerated the spread of "fake news" and organized misinformation. Data from the Edelman Trust Barometer reveals a catastrophic decline in public trust, with the media now being the least trusted institution globally. This erosion of trust in information sources creates a toxic environment for brands. When consumers can't trust the news, politicians, or even their own social feeds, their skepticism naturally extends to corporate messaging. This forces brands to operate on a battlefield where their greatest asset—trust—has been fundamentally devalued, making it harder than ever to establish credibility and connect with consumers.
Privacy is the New Battleground
Key Insight 2
Narrator: One of the most explosive fronts in the war for trust is data privacy. The book explores the complex duality of privacy: it is simultaneously framed as a fundamental human right and treated as a tradable asset. Nothing illustrates this conflict more starkly than the Cambridge Analytica scandal. In 2018, it was revealed that the political consulting firm had improperly harvested the personal data of up to 87 million Facebook users. A seemingly harmless personality quiz app had collected not only the data of its users but also the data of their entire friend networks, all without their consent.
This data was then used to build sophisticated psychological profiles to target voters with hyper-personalized, manipulative political advertising during the 2016 U.S. election. The fallout was immense. Facebook’s reputation was shattered, its CEO Mark Zuckerberg was called to testify before Congress, and the scandal triggered a massive "tech-lash." Consumers were suddenly confronted with the dark side of the data economy. This event, along with the implementation of regulations like the EU's GDPR, marked a turning point. It solidified the idea that brands are custodians of personal information, and any misuse is a profound betrayal of trust. For businesses, the message is clear: the collection and use of data is no longer a back-end technical issue but a central pillar of their ethical reputation.
Meaningful Connections Must Replace Intrusive Ads
Key Insight 3
Narrator: The traditional advertising model is broken. Consumers are bombarded with so many marketing messages—a condition the book calls "infosmog"—that they have become experts at tuning them out. The rise of the "#SkipAd" button is a powerful metaphor for the public's relationship with advertising. Research from Havas Group is particularly damning, revealing that most people wouldn't care if 74% of the brands they use simply disappeared. Furthermore, the study found that 60% of all content created by brands is seen as poor, irrelevant, or failing to deliver.
In this environment, trust in advertising executives is astonishingly low. The most powerful and trusted form of marketing remains what it has always been: word-of-mouth. A recommendation from a friend or family member cuts through the noise in a way no polished ad campaign ever can. The book argues that the way forward is not to shout louder but to create "connections with meaning." This requires a fundamental shift from interruption to engagement. Brands must earn their audience's attention by providing genuine value, fostering communities, and empowering their customers to become their most effective advocates.
Conscious Capitalism is the New Mandate
Key Insight 4
Narrator: A growing number of consumers, particularly Millennials and Gen-Z, no longer see brands as just providers of goods and services. They expect them to be active corporate citizens with a clear moral compass. This has given rise to "conscious capitalism" and "brand activism," where companies are rewarded for taking a stand on social and political issues. Consumers want to feel morally good about their purchases and are increasingly choosing to buy from or boycott brands based on their values.
Patagonia stands as a primary example of this principle in action. The outdoor apparel company has built its identity on environmental activism. Its most famous campaign ran on Black Friday with the headline, "Don't Buy This Jacket," urging people to consider the environmental cost of consumerism. This seemingly counterintuitive message resonated deeply with its audience, reinforcing the brand's authenticity and, paradoxically, boosting its sales. Patagonia demonstrates that having a purpose beyond profit—and acting on it consistently—is a powerful way to build a fiercely loyal community that shares the brand's values.
Radical Transparency is Non-Negotiable
Key Insight 5
Narrator: In a distrusting world, transparency is a brand's most powerful weapon. Consumers are demanding to know more about the products they buy, from the price breakdown to the provenance of the materials. The book highlights how innovative brands are leveraging "radical transparency" to build trust. For instance, the apparel company Everlane breaks down the exact cost of producing each garment—from materials to labor to transport—and also offers a "Choose What You Pay" model on overstock items, transparently explaining what each price point covers.
This trend is being accelerated by technology. The author points to blockchain as a revolutionary tool for transparency. By creating an unchangeable digital ledger, blockchain can track a product's entire journey from its origin to the consumer. A coffee bean, for example, can be traced back to the specific farm where it was grown, verifying that it was ethically sourced. This technology moves brands from simply telling stories about their supply chain to providing verifiable, auditable proof, placing unprecedented power and control in the hands of the consumer.
Authenticity is an Action, Not an Advertisement
Key Insight 6
Narrator: Ultimately, The Post-Truth Business argues that all these threads—trust, privacy, purpose, and transparency—are woven together by a single concept: authenticity. However, true authenticity is not a marketing strategy or a branding veneer. It cannot be faked. It must be a core business practice, embedded in everything a company does. The book contrasts the disastrous Pepsi ad with the highly successful "Truth" anti-smoking campaign.
The "Truth" campaign didn't just tell teens that smoking was bad for them. Instead, it armed them with the truth about the manipulative tactics of the tobacco industry, empowering them to make their own informed choices. It was edgy, honest, and brutally effective, leading to a dramatic decline in youth smoking rates. The campaign worked because its moral compass was clear and its message was rooted in unvarnished truth. It didn't just say it was authentic; it was authentic. This is the central lesson for any brand trying to thrive in a post-truth world: you must "do it and be it," not just "say it."
Conclusion
Narrator: The single most important takeaway from The Post-Truth Business is that trust has become the most valuable and fragile currency in the modern economy. In an era defined by skepticism and misinformation, the old rules of marketing no longer apply. Building a successful, resilient brand is no longer about crafting the most persuasive message or the cleverest campaign. It is about building a fundamentally trustworthy organization from the inside out, where authenticity is reflected in every action, from supply chain ethics to customer service.
The book leaves every business leader with a profound challenge. It forces a moment of introspection, asking a question that is both simple and deeply complex: Is your brand's authenticity a story you tell, or is it a truth you live? In the post-truth world, consumers can tell the difference, and their verdict will ultimately determine your fate.