
The Broken Social Contract
9 minHow to Fix It
Introduction
Narrator: Imagine a typical morning. You wake up, make coffee with water from a public utility, and use a phone whose GPS technology was funded by the government. You drive to work in a foreign car built in a domestic factory, on roads paid for by taxpayers. You board a flight regulated by a national agency, on a plane whose core technology originated in military research. This complex, invisible web of cooperation between individuals, businesses, and the state is the social contract in action. It’s the magic that makes modern life possible. But what happens when that web begins to tear?
In his book, The Broken Social Contract, author Oren Cass argues that this delicate balance has been dangerously disrupted. He provides a stark diagnosis of how the scales have tipped dramatically in favor of corporate power, leaving citizens and governments behind, and offers a roadmap for how we might begin to repair the damage.
From Public Good to Private Profit: The Insulin Tragedy
Key Insight 1
Narrator: The story of insulin is a powerful tale of two eras. When it was discovered in the 1920s, its creators sold the patent for just three dollars, ensuring the life-saving drug would be accessible to all. The president of Merck at the time declared, "We try never to forget that medicine is for the people. It is not for the profits." This was the ethos of stakeholder capitalism, where a company's responsibility extended to its employees, customers, and community.
This worldview was shattered by the rise of shareholder primacy, an idea championed by economist Milton Friedman, who argued a company’s only social responsibility is to increase its profits. This philosophy took hold in the 1980s, epitomized by the "greed is good" mantra. The consequences are tragically illustrated by the modern insulin crisis. Families like the Corleys in West Virginia find themselves spending up to $18,000 a year on healthcare for their diabetic daughter. Worse, young adults like Alec Smith and Jesy Boyd have died after rationing their insulin because they couldn't afford the exorbitant price, a price set by a pharmaceutical industry that now prioritizes shareholder returns over human lives. This shift from a stakeholder to a shareholder model is a foundational crack in the social contract.
When Government Fails, Who Fills the Void?
Key Insight 2
Narrator: In September 2017, Hurricane Maria devastated Puerto Rico. In the aftermath, the U.S. government's response was tragically slow and inefficient. The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) struggled to distribute basic supplies, leaving millions without food, water, or power for weeks. The official death toll, initially reported as 64, was later revised to nearly 3,000, with many deaths attributed to the failed response.
Into this vacuum stepped chef José Andrés and his non-profit, World Central Kitchen. Bypassing bureaucracy, Andrés mobilized local chefs and restaurants, and within weeks was serving over 140,000 hot meals a day, vastly outperforming the federal government. This story exemplifies a core argument of the book: as governments become less effective, private actors and corporations are filling the void. Cass argues that the U.S. government is hampered by "kludgeocracy"—a system of overlapping, complex, and often contradictory policies—and "vetocracy," where political polarization allows small groups to block meaningful action. This paralysis is worsened by corporate capture, where lobbyists effectively write legislation, ensuring the rules of the game favor their interests, not the public's.
The Fading Power of the Worker
Key Insight 3
Narrator: The golden age of the American worker was forged in conflict. In 1936, autoworkers in Flint, Michigan, staged a 44-day sit-down strike inside a General Motors plant. Their victory forced GM to recognize their union, the UAW, and sparked a wave of unionization across the country. In the decades that followed, union membership soared, and with it, wages and benefits. As Martin Luther King Jr. observed, the labor movement "lifted the whole nation to undreamed of levels of production."
However, this power has dramatically eroded. A critical turning point came in 1981 when President Ronald Reagan fired over 11,000 striking air traffic controllers. This sent a clear signal to corporate America: unions could be broken. Compounded by globalization, automation, and the relentless pressure of shareholder capitalism, union membership plummeted. The result is a staggering divergence. Between 1978 and 2018, CEO compensation grew by over 940 percent, while the typical worker's pay rose by just 12 percent. Without a strong collective voice, workers have lost their seat at the table, and their share of the economic pie has shrunk accordingly.
The Global Wormhole: How Corporations Dodge the Taxman
Key Insight 4
Narrator: When an Italian man named Marco buys a leather belt from an Italian craftsman after clicking a Google ad, the transaction seems simple. But the few euros Google earns for that click embark on a dizzying journey. Through a maneuver nicknamed the "Double Irish with a Dutch Sandwich," the profit is routed from Ireland to a shell company in the Netherlands, and then to another Irish-registered company that is tax-resident in Bermuda—a tax haven with a 0% corporate tax rate.
This is not an anomaly; it is the system. Cass reveals how multinational corporations like Google, Apple, and others have perfected the art of tax avoidance, exploiting 20th-century tax laws to shift hundreds of billions in profits to low- or no-tax jurisdictions. This "race to the bottom" has starved governments of essential revenue. In 1952, corporate taxes made up 32% of U.S. federal revenue; today, it's less than 7%. This lost income is precisely what’s needed to fund infrastructure, education, and the social safety net, further weakening the government's side of the social contract.
A World at a Crossroads: Open Democracy or Closed Control?
Key Insight 5
Narrator: The book argues the world is facing a fundamental choice between two competing models for the future. On one side is the closed, authoritarian model of China. After 1978, the Communist Party engineered an economic miracle, lifting 800 million people out of poverty by embracing market economics while retaining absolute political control. The social contract is clear: the state delivers stability and prosperity in exchange for political submission.
On the other side is the open, democratic model best exemplified by the Nordic countries. During the COVID-19 pandemic, Denmark responded not with mass layoffs, but by negotiating with employers and unions to have the government pay up to 90% of private-sector salaries. This protected both workers and businesses. The Nordic model balances free-market capitalism with high taxes that fund robust social safety nets, fostering a high degree of social trust and cohesion. Cass argues that Western nations, particularly the U.S., must learn from these open models to repair their own frayed social contracts and offer a compelling alternative to the rise of techno-authoritarianism.
Conclusion
Narrator: The single most important takeaway from The Broken Social Contract is that our current trajectory is not an accident; it is the result of deliberate choices that have prioritized shareholder profits above all other societal considerations. The system is not just fraying at the edges—it is fundamentally broken. To fix it requires not just tinkering, but a conscious effort to rewrite the rules and rebalance the duties and responsibilities between corporations, governments, and the citizens they are meant to serve.
The book leaves us with a haunting vision of the future. A Filipino family in 2030, displaced by a climate-fueled typhoon, must choose where to go. Do they move to a nativist West with a threadbare safety net, or to a surveillance state like China that offers work but demands total obedience? Their choice is our choice. The question is not whether the world of 2030 will be different, but whether we will have the courage to build one where being elite in a thriving society is seen as better than being elite in a world that is burning down.