Aibrary Logo
Podcast thumbnail

The Big Nine

10 min

How the Tech Titans and Their Thinking Machines Could Warp Humanity

Introduction

Narrator: What if the future of humanity—our values, our choices, our very autonomy—was being coded into existence by just nine corporations? What if six of them, based in the U.S., were driven by the relentless pressures of market forces and short-term profits, while the other three, in China, were inextricably linked to the authoritarian ambitions of their government? This isn't a distant sci-fi scenario; it's the present reality. In her book The Big Nine, futurist Amy Webb reveals that this dangerous dichotomy is creating a future that may not serve humanity's best interests. She provides a stark warning about the unchecked power of these tech titans and their thinking machines, but also offers a crucial blueprint for how we can reclaim control before it’s too late.

The Two Tribes Shaping Our Future

Key Insight 1

Narrator: At the heart of Webb's analysis is the assertion that the future of artificial intelligence is not being developed by a diverse, global community. Instead, it is controlled by two distinct and powerful "tribes." In the West, there is the G-MAFIA: Google, Microsoft, Amazon, Facebook, IBM, and Apple. These companies operate in a world driven by consumerism and shareholder demands, forcing them to prioritize rapid development and short-term profitability. Their primary motivation is the market.

In the East, there is the BAT: Baidu, Alibaba, and Tencent. These Chinese giants are not just corporations; they are instruments of the state, deeply integrated with the government's grand strategy to become the world's undisputed AI leader by 2030. Their primary motivation is fulfilling the government's agenda. This creates a fundamental conflict. While the G-MAFIA builds AI optimized for clicks, engagement, and consumption, the BAT builds AI optimized for surveillance, social engineering, and control.

Webb illustrates the chilling potential of the Chinese model with the story of its Social Credit System. This AI-powered system monitors citizens' behavior, from traffic violations to heroic acts, and assigns them a score. A low score can prevent someone from getting a job, buying a home, or sending their children to good schools. In some cities, the faces of jaywalkers are displayed on public billboards. The system's official slogan reveals its goal: "allowing the trustworthy to roam everywhere under heaven while making it hard for the discredited to take a single step." This is the reality of AI development when its core value is state control, not human flourishing.

The Homogeneity Problem: How Bias Gets Baked In

Key Insight 2

Narrator: The problem isn't just the conflicting values of the two tribes, but also the nature of the people within them. Webb argues that the developers building our AI future are a remarkably homogenous group: overwhelmingly male, affluent, highly educated, and sharing a narrow set of cultural and political worldviews. This lack of diversity—in race, gender, ideology, and life experience—is dangerous because the biases of the creators are inevitably programmed into their creations.

Webb points to the work of Harvard professor Latanya Sweeney to show how this plays out. In 2013, when Sweeney, who is Black, Googled her own name, an ad appeared with the text: “Latanya Sweeney, Arrested?” The AI powering Google’s ads had determined that her name was "Black-identifying" and, based on biased training data reflecting historical arrest rates, concluded that a search for her name was likely a search for a criminal record. The system wasn't designed to be racist; it was designed to optimize for clicks. But because it was built by a homogenous team and trained on biased data, it produced a racist outcome. This is a clear example of how a system built without diverse perspectives can perpetuate and amplify societal harms.

Death by a Thousand Paper Cuts

Key Insight 3

Narrator: The threat from AI, Webb contends, is not a single, dramatic event like a robot uprising. Instead, it is a slow, creeping erosion of our values, privacy, and autonomy—a death by a thousand paper cuts. These are the small, unintended consequences that accumulate over time, subtly reshaping our world for the worse.

A powerful example of this is the story of Dr. David Dao, a passenger on an overbooked United Airlines flight. When no one volunteered to give up their seat, an algorithm selected four passengers to be removed. Dr. Dao refused, explaining he was a doctor who needed to see patients. The airline staff, ceding their authority to the algorithm, did not exercise human judgment or empathy. Instead, they had security forcibly drag him from the plane, injuring him in the process. The algorithm was optimized for efficiency, not for compassion or context. This incident reveals a world where human staff defer to flawed, unfeeling systems, and where personal circumstances are ignored in the name of optimization. Each of these "paper cuts"—from biased ad results to dehumanizing travel experiences—weakens our societal fabric.

Three Paths to Tomorrow: Optimistic, Pragmatic, or Catastrophic

Key Insight 4

Narrator: Webb doesn't just diagnose the problem; she projects it into three possible futures to show us what’s at stake.

The Optimistic Scenario is one of global collaboration. The U.S. and its allies form a "Global Alliance on Intelligence Augmentation" (GAIA) to establish shared ethical standards. The Big Nine agree to a new social contract where individuals own their personal data. AI becomes a tool that augments human creativity and intelligence, helping to solve major world problems.

The Pragmatic Scenario is a messy, fragmented future. The G-MAFIA consolidates, with the world split between two dominant, non-interoperable ecosystems, perhaps an "Applezon" and a Google-led consortium. This creates a digital caste system where your choice of tech platform dictates your opportunities. Society becomes plagued by "learned helplessness" as people grow overly dependent on flawed, competing AI systems.

The Catastrophic Scenario depicts the rise of the "Réngōng Zhìnéng Dynasty." In this future, the West fails to create a coherent strategy. China's state-controlled AI model becomes dominant, exported globally through its Belt and Road Initiative. The world is blanketed by a Chinese-led surveillance network. Human autonomy is extinguished, democracy withers, and the book ends with a chilling vision of digital annihilation. These scenarios are not predictions, but warnings of the divergent paths that lie before us.

The Pebble and the Boulder: A Call to Action

Key Insight 5

Narrator: To avoid the worst-case scenarios, Webb argues that we need courageous leadership and collective action. She uses a powerful parable from Vint Cerf, one of the internet's co-designers, to illustrate this point. A community lives at the base of a mountain, where a giant boulder sits precariously, threatening to crush their village. One person alone cannot stop it. But if every single person in the community goes up the mountain and places a small pebble in its path, together they can slow the boulder and divert its course.

The boulder is AI, and we are the villagers. Webb outlines the "pebbles" that each part of society must contribute. Governments must create national AI strategies and invest in research that prioritizes public good. The Big Nine must transform their business practices to prioritize ethics, transparency, and long-term safety over short-term profit. Universities must reform their curricula to produce more ethically-minded and diverse technologists. And finally, individuals must educate themselves, question the autonomous systems in their lives, and vote for leaders who understand the stakes. The future of AI is not a problem for someone else to solve; it requires everyone to pick up a pebble.

Conclusion

Narrator: The single most important takeaway from The Big Nine is that the future of AI is not something that is happening to us; it is being actively built right now, and the current architects are leading us down a perilous path. The unchecked, conflicting ambitions of a handful of corporations and one authoritarian government are programming a future that prioritizes profit and control over humanity.

Amy Webb’s work is more than a fascinating analysis; it is an urgent call to action. It challenges the comforting but dangerous assumption that technology will magically solve its own problems. The book leaves us with a profound and practical question: recognizing that we all live in the shadow of this immense technological boulder, what pebble will you contribute to help steer it towards a safer, more equitable future?

00:00/00:00