
The Un-Career Playbook
12 minThe New Way to Start Out, Step Up, or Start Over in Your Career
Golden Hook & Introduction
SECTION
Michelle: Alright Mark, I have a controversial statement for you: 'Follow your passion' is probably the worst career advice you can give someone starting out today. Mark: Whoa, okay. You're coming in hot. That's basically the entire plot of every inspirational movie. Are you saying we should all just get boring, practical jobs and be miserable? Michelle: Not at all! But it's about being strategic, not just emotional. And that's the core idea in a fantastic book we're diving into today: Strategize to Win by Carla Harris. Mark: Carla Harris... the name sounds familiar. She’s a big deal on Wall Street, right? Michelle: A legend. A veteran investment banker who navigated some of the most turbulent economic times imaginable. What’s fascinating is that she wrote this book after seeing a whole generation of professionals, especially after the 2009 financial crisis, take jobs out of sheer desperation, not strategy. Mark: I can relate to that. People were just grabbing the first lifeboat they could find. Michelle: Exactly. And years later, they looked up and found themselves completely stuck, on a career path they never chose. Harris wanted to give them the tools to get unstuck, or to avoid that trap in the first place. Mark: Ah, so this isn't just theory. This is battle-tested advice from the trenches. Michelle: Precisely. And her first big argument completely flips the script on how we think about choosing a career. She says the skills that help you land a position won’t be the same skills that will insure your success in that role. Mark: Huh. That feels deeply true and also slightly terrifying. It’s like being given the keys to a car, but no one teaches you how to actually drive it on the highway. Michelle: That’s a perfect analogy. And it’s why she argues we need to stop obsessing over the job title—the shiny car—and start focusing on something much more fundamental.
The Myth of the 'Perfect Plan': Why 'Content' Trumps Title
SECTION
Mark: Okay, I'm listening. If not the job title, then what? What's the secret? Michelle: The secret is what she calls 'content.' And she argues that in today's economy, the content of a job is far more important than the job itself. Mark: 'Content.' Honestly, that sounds a bit like corporate jargon. What does she actually mean by that? Isn't that just... the stuff you do? Michelle: It is, but it's about defining that 'stuff' with intention. The content is the collection of verbs in your job description. Are you analyzing, persuading, building, organizing, problem-solving? It's about identifying the core activities that you're good at and that you actually enjoy, independent of the title on your business card. Mark: I guess that makes sense. But when you're 22 with a mountain of student loans, 'content' feels like a luxury. A job title pays the bills. It's a clear signal of status and progress. Michelle: I hear you. And Harris acknowledges that reality. But she tells a great story that makes this idea incredibly concrete. It’s about a recent college graduate who desperately wanted to work in ad sales for a big, glamorous magazine. That was her dream job. Mark: A classic goal. Very The Devil Wears Prada, but for the sales department. Michelle: Exactly. But the economy was tough, and every ad sales job was going to seasoned executives with a decade of experience. She couldn't get her foot in the door anywhere. She was getting desperate. Mark: The classic catch-22. You can't get the job without experience, and you can't get experience without the job. Michelle: Right. So, instead of giving up or just taking a random office job, she made a strategic pivot. She took a job in telemarketing, selling home security systems over the phone. Mark: Wow, that’s a world away from high-fashion magazine ads. That sounds like a step backward, not forward. Michelle: From a 'title' perspective, yes. It was completely unglamorous. But from a 'content' perspective, it was genius. What is the absolute core skill of ad sales? Mark: Persuading people to buy something they might not think they need. Cold calling, building rapport quickly, closing a deal. Michelle: Bingo. And that's exactly what she spent a year doing, day in and day out, on the phone. She wasn't just selling security systems; she was mastering the content of sales. She was building a toolkit of pure, transferable skills. Mark: Okay, I'm starting to see it now. She was in a sales gym, lifting the weights, even if the gym itself wasn't pretty. Michelle: That’s a great way to put it. So, a year later, she applies for that magazine ad sales job again. The hiring manager is skeptical, looking at her resume. 'Telemarketing? How is that relevant to our brand?' Mark: Yeah, that’s the moment of truth. How did she handle it? Michelle: She didn't defend the title. She sold the content. She said, 'For the last year, my entire job has been to get on the phone with a complete stranger, build enough trust in three minutes to get them to listen, and convince them to make a purchase. I can do it over the phone. I can definitely do it face-to-face for a brand I actually love.' Mark: That's a killer pitch. She reframed it entirely. So the 'content' is the verb, not the noun. It's the selling, not the telemarketer. Michelle: You've got it. And she got the job. That story is the perfect illustration of the principle. The telemarketing job wasn't her destination; it was a strategic vehicle to acquire the skills she needed for her destination. Mark: It also highlights the danger of the opposite approach, which Harris also talks about. The people who, during that same crisis, just took any job to pay the bills. Michelle: Yes, the cautionary tale. She saw so many people take jobs in, say, data entry or administrative support when their goal was marketing. A few years later, when the economy improved, they were stuck. They couldn't explain how their experience prepared them for the job they actually wanted. They had a resume gap in their desired 'content.' Mark: They were in the wrong gym, lifting the wrong weights. And now they're trying to compete against people who have been training for this specific event the whole time. Michelle: It's a powerful and sobering thought. Every job is either moving you closer to your goal or further away. There's rarely a neutral position.
Career as a Sales Transaction: Selling Your Story
SECTION
Mark: That makes total sense. But it brings up the next huge question. It’s one thing to acquire the right 'content,' but it's another to convince a skeptical hiring manager that your telemarketing job is relevant to their fancy magazine. That's the hard part, right? The sales pitch. Michelle: It is the hard part. And this is where Harris’s second major idea comes in, which is just as transformative. She says you have to stop thinking of a job search as an application and start thinking of it as a sales transaction. Mark: A sales transaction? Explain that. Michelle: In any sale, you have a buyer and a seller. The job applicant is the seller, and the interviewer is the buyer. A bad salesperson just lists the features of their product. 'My product has 5GB of RAM and a dual-core processor.' A good salesperson figures out what the buyer's problem is and explains how their product solves it. Mark: Right, they sell the benefit, not the feature. 'This will make your life easier,' not 'This has a lithium-ion battery.' Michelle: Exactly. So, in an interview, the 'features' are the lines on your resume. 'I worked at Company X,' 'I have a degree in Y.' The 'benefit' is how your unique collection of skills and experiences—your story—can solve the company's problem and help them win. Mark: So you need to be a detective first, to figure out what they're really buying. Michelle: Yes! And to illustrate this, Harris tells her own story, which is just incredible. When she was at Harvard, she applied for a highly competitive internship on Wall Street. Mark: Okay, the big leagues. I'm assuming she had a ton of finance internships already lined up on her resume. Michelle: Not at all. Her primary work experience at that point was working at McDonald's through high school. Mark: Wait, seriously? McDonald's to a Wall Street investment bank? How on earth do you bridge that gap? I can just imagine the interviewer's face. Michelle: And that's the point. She knew she couldn't sell the 'feature'—the title 'McDonald's Crew Member.' So she sold the benefits. When the interviewer asked about her experience, she didn't just say, 'I worked the cash register.' Mark: What did she say? Michelle: She told a story. She said, 'While I was there, I was named Crewmember of the Month within my first 90 days. I was promoted to Crew Chief while I was still in high school. I was constantly suggesting ideas to the manager to increase sales during our shift. And on most nights, I had the highest-grossing cash register in the entire restaurant.' Mark: Whoa. That is brilliant. She wasn't selling 'I flip burgers.' She was selling 'I am a top performer in a high-pressure, results-driven environment. I am commercially oriented, I can connect with people, and I have an appetite to win.' Michelle: You just nailed it. She translated her experience. She understood what the 'buyer'—the Wall Street firm—was actually looking for. They weren't buying finance experience from an intern; they were buying raw talent, drive, and a commercial mindset. She showed them she had those things in spades, just in a different arena. Mark: And she got the internship, obviously. Michelle: She did. And it launched her career. It's the ultimate proof that it’s not about the job you had; it’s about the story you tell about it. You have to connect the dots for them. Mark: I love that. But I have to ask the skeptical question. Does this only work for someone as exceptional as Carla Harris, who was also a student at Harvard? That's a pretty big safety net. Can a regular person from a state school pull this off? Michelle: That’s a fair challenge, and it’s a criticism some readers have had—that her advice is geared toward the hyper-ambitious. But I think the principle is universal. The context might change, but the strategy remains the same. Whether you're moving from retail to tech, or from a non-profit to a corporate role, the task is to identify the core, transferable skills—the 'content'—and then frame them as a solution to your target employer's problems. It’s about owning your story, no matter what it is. Mark: So it’s less about having a prestigious background and more about being a better storyteller and a better detective about what the other side needs. Michelle: Precisely. It democratizes the process. It gives the power back to the individual to define their own value, rather than letting a past job title define it for them.
Synthesis & Takeaways
SECTION
Michelle: When you put the two ideas together, it’s a really powerful one-two punch for navigating your career. Mark: Let me see if I can stitch it together. Step one is to deconstruct your job, and any potential job, into its core 'content'—the skills, the verbs. You focus on acquiring the content you need for your long-term goal, even if the job title isn't glamorous. Michelle: Perfect. That’s the strategic acquisition phase. Mark: Then, step two is the sales phase. You take that content you've acquired and you package it into a compelling story. You don't just list your experience; you translate it to show how you can solve the specific problems of the company you're talking to. Michelle: Exactly. First, you decouple your skills from your job title. Then, you re-package those skills into a narrative that solves the 'buyer's' problem. It's a two-step move that gives you incredible power and flexibility, no matter what the economy is doing. Mark: It feels like it transforms you from a passive job-seeker, just hoping someone likes your resume, into an active, strategic player. An entrepreneur of your own career. Michelle: That's the goal. It's about taking agency. So for someone listening right now who feels a bit stuck or directionless, what's the first, most practical step they could take away from this? Michelle: Harris would say to put the job boards away for a moment and ask yourself three simple questions. First: If money were no object, what 'content' would fill my days? What activities energize me? Second: What kinds of jobs, regardless of industry, contain that content? And third: What skills or experiences do I need to become an attractive candidate for those roles? Mark: I like that. You start with the 'what,' not the 'where.' You build the career from the inside out, based on the work itself, not on a title you think you're supposed to want. Michelle: It's a fundamental shift in perspective. And it can be the difference between a career that happens to you and a career that you build for yourself. Mark: It makes me think about all the unexpected 'content' people have in their jobs. The barista who is an expert in high-speed logistics and customer de-escalation. The librarian who is a master of data architecture. I'd love to hear what 'content' our listeners are discovering in their own jobs. Let us know what surprising skills you've found in unexpected places. Michelle: That’s a fantastic question. It’s all about seeing the value that’s already there. Mark: A powerful and genuinely useful way to look at the world. Michelle: This is Aibrary, signing off.