Aibrary Logo
Podcast thumbnail

Physics of the Impossible

9 min

A Scientific Exploration into the World of Phasers, Force Fields, Teleportation, and Time Travel

Introduction

Narrator: What if we could erect invisible shields to protect our cities, travel between stars in an instant, and even journey through time itself? For centuries, these ideas have been the exclusive domain of science fiction. But what if they weren't? What if the line between the fantastical and the physically possible is simply a matter of time and scientific understanding? In his book, Physics of the Impossible, theoretical physicist Michio Kaku embarks on a scientific exploration into these very concepts, transforming them from mere fantasy into a roadmap for humanity's potential future. Kaku argues that by seriously examining what we deem "impossible," we can not only predict the technologies of the future but also push the boundaries of science today.

The 'Impossible' Is a Temporary State

Key Insight 1

Narrator: At the heart of Kaku's analysis is the idea that "impossibility" is a relative and often temporary concept. History is littered with pronouncements from brilliant minds who confidently declared certain technologies impossible, only to be proven wrong. In the late 19th century, the renowned physicist Lord Kelvin, a giant in his field, stated that "heavier than air" flying machines were impossible. Just a few years later, the Wright brothers took to the sky at Kitty Hawk. Similarly, when Robert Goddard, the father of modern rocketry, proposed that rockets could travel in the vacuum of space, he was publicly ridiculed by The New York Times. The paper incorrectly argued that a rocket needed air to push against. Decades later, as Apollo 11 landed on the moon, the Times issued a formal retraction.

To navigate this shifting landscape, Kaku classifies impossible technologies into three categories. Class I impossibilities are technologies that, while currently unachievable, do not violate any known laws of physics and might be realized within a century. Class II impossibilities are at the very edge of our understanding, potentially achievable in millennia or millions of years. Class III impossibilities, like perpetual motion machines, directly violate the known laws of physics and would require a fundamental rewriting of our understanding of the universe. This framework allows us to distinguish between engineering challenges and true physical barriers.

Class I Impossibilities Are Tomorrow's Engineering Projects

Key Insight 2

Narrator: Many of science fiction's most iconic technologies fall into Kaku's Class I category. Consider the force field, a staple of franchises like Star Trek. While a single, invisible, impenetrable shield is beyond our grasp, its properties can be approximated by combining existing and emerging technologies. Physicist Ady Herschcovitch, for example, invented a "plasma window" in 1995. By heating gas to 12,000°F, he created a contained plasma that could separate a vacuum from open air, acting as a primitive barrier. Kaku envisions a multi-layered shield combining plasma windows to vaporize projectiles, powerful laser curtains to shoot down incoming objects, and a super-strong lattice of carbon nanotubes.

Invisibility is another Class I concept making the leap from fiction to reality. The breakthrough lies in "metamaterials," substances engineered with properties not found in nature. In 2006, researchers at Duke University created a metamaterial that could bend microwave radiation around a copper cylinder, effectively making it invisible to microwaves. While creating a metamaterial for the much smaller wavelengths of visible light requires nanotechnology, the proof of concept is there. These technologies are not magic; they are the result of applying our deepest understanding of electromagnetism and quantum physics to achieve what was once thought to be purely imaginary.

Class II Impossibilities Require Harnessing the Cosmos

Key Insight 3

Narrator: Class II impossibilities, such as faster-than-light (FTL) travel and time travel, push the known laws of physics to their absolute limits. Einstein's theory of relativity famously establishes the speed of light as the universe's ultimate speed limit. As an object approaches light speed, its mass increases towards infinity, requiring infinite energy to push it further. However, Einstein's own theories provide potential loopholes. General relativity suggests that spacetime itself is not fixed, but can be bent, stretched, and warped.

This opens the door to speculative concepts like the Alcubierre "warp drive." Proposed by physicist Miguel Alcubierre, this drive doesn't propel a ship through space, but rather moves space itself. It would theoretically work by contracting spacetime in front of the ship and expanding it behind, creating a "warp bubble" that rides a wave of spacetime to its destination, arriving faster than a beam of light could. Similarly, time travel into the past might be possible by navigating a "wormhole," a theoretical tunnel connecting two distant points in spacetime. The catch is that both concepts require "exotic matter" with negative energy, a substance whose existence is theoretical and would require the energy of a star or black hole to create and stabilize.

Class III Impossibilities Challenge the Foundations of Reality

Key Insight 4

Narrator: Class III impossibilities are those that appear to violate the fundamental laws of physics as we currently understand them. The most famous example is the perpetual motion machine, a device that can run forever without an energy source. The quest for such a device has a long and often fraudulent history. In 1813, Charles Redheffer charged audiences in New York to see his machine, which ran indefinitely. The hoax was exposed when engineer Robert Fulton noticed an uneven wobble and, upon investigation, found a hidden belt connected to an old man in the attic, turning a crank.

Perpetual motion machines are impossible because they violate the first and second laws of thermodynamics. The first law, the conservation of energy, states that energy cannot be created or destroyed. The second law states that in any closed system, entropy, or disorder, always increases. A perpetual motion machine would have to either create energy from nothing or operate with perfect efficiency, producing zero entropy—both of which are forbidden.

Another Class III impossibility is precognition, or seeing the future. This concept violates the principle of causality, the idea that cause must always precede effect. While quantum physics introduces bizarre ideas, like particles seemingly traveling backward in time, these phenomena do not allow for information to be sent to the past. For precognition to be real, our entire understanding of time and causality would have to be fundamentally overthrown.

Conclusion

Narrator: The single most important takeaway from Physics of the Impossible is that the rigorous study of the "impossible" is not a frivolous exercise, but a vital engine of scientific discovery. By pushing at the edges of what we know, we clarify the boundaries of physical law and often stumble upon unexpected breakthroughs. The pursuit of alchemy led to modern chemistry, and the quest for perpetual motion machines helped formulate the laws of thermodynamics.

Michio Kaku leaves us with a profound challenge: to look at the world with a sense of wonder and to question our assumptions about what is and isn't possible. The technologies that define our world today—from GPS systems that rely on Einstein's relativity to the lasers in our grocery scanners—were once the stuff of impossible dreams. The question, then, is not whether the impossibilities of today will become the realities of tomorrow, but which ones will, and what new laws of physics we will discover on the journey to get there.

00:00/00:00