
How To
10 minAbsurd Scientific Advice for Common Real-World Problems
Introduction
Narrator: What if you wanted to throw a pool party, but instead of buying a standard above-ground pool, you decided to build one from scratch using Gruyère cheese? How thick would the cheese walls need to be to hold the water without bursting? Or what if you needed to cross a river, and your first thought wasn't to find a bridge, but to boil the entire river dry? These aren't just idle, bizarre questions; they are precisely the kind of problems explored with rigorous scientific detail in Randall Munroe's book, How To: Absurd Scientific Advice for Common Real-World Problems. Munroe, the creator of the popular webcomic xkcd, applies fundamental principles of physics, engineering, and mathematics to everyday tasks, taking them to their most logical, and often catastrophic, extremes. The result is a hilarious and surprisingly profound journey into the art of overthinking, revealing that the most impractical solutions often teach us the most about the world we live in.
Redefining 'Possible' with Physics
Key Insight 1
Narrator: The book immediately establishes its core premise: if you want to achieve something extraordinary, like jumping incredibly high, you don’t have to rely on conventional methods. Instead, you can use physics to "cheat." Munroe explains that while the best athletes can only jump a few feet, pole vaulters can clear heights of over 20 feet. The secret isn't the springiness of the pole, but its ability to efficiently convert a runner's horizontal speed into vertical height.
This principle of "cheating" is then taken to its most absurd conclusion. If you truly want to set a high-jump record, you must exploit aerodynamics and atmospheric conditions. This leads to the incredible true story of pilots Steve Fossett and Einar Enevoldson. In 2006, they sought to break the glider altitude record by riding stratospheric mountain waves over the Andes in Argentina. These are rare, powerful updrafts that can extend into the upper atmosphere. Wearing pressure suits, they skillfully maneuvered their specialized glider into these rising air currents, ascending to over 50,000 feet. They were only forced to turn back because their pressure suits inflated so much in the thin air that they could no longer operate the controls. Munroe humorously concludes that to truly jump high, one simply needs to construct a suit shaped like a sailplane, jump into the wind, and ride it into the stratosphere. It’s not a jump, he notes, but a flight—a perfect illustration of how redefining a problem with physics can lead to spectacular, if impractical, results.
The Perils of Engineering Without Foresight
Key Insight 2
Narrator: While Munroe’s advice is comical, it often carries a serious underlying message about the unintended consequences of large-scale projects. This is powerfully demonstrated in the chapter on throwing a pool party, which explores how one might source a massive amount of water. One of the more ambitious methods suggested is to simply divert a nearby river.
To illustrate the potential outcome, the book recounts the accidental creation of the Salton Sea. In 1905, engineers digging irrigation canals from the Colorado River made a critical miscalculation. The water flowing into a new canal began eroding its path, carving a deeper and wider channel until it captured the entire river. The Colorado River was completely diverted, flooding a vast, dry valley and creating California's largest lake. Munroe points out with dark humor that while the new sea was briefly a popular resort destination, the long-term consequences were disastrous. Decades of agricultural runoff and increasing salinity turned the lake into an environmental catastrophe, creating a toxic, foul-smelling wasteland. The story serves as a stark warning: when you undertake massive engineering projects, even for something as fun as a pool party, you must consider the consequences. As Munroe cheekily advises, you can worry about the ghost towns and ecological collapse tomorrow; for now, it's pool party time!
The Unforeseen Complexities of Moving Things
Key Insight 3
Narrator: The book frequently examines the logistics of moving objects, whether it's the entire contents of a house or a single package sent from space. In "How to Mail a Package," Munroe tackles the immense challenges of getting an object from the International Space Station back to Earth, from surviving the fiery heat of reentry to controlling the landing location. The most fascinating part of the problem, however, is what happens after it lands.
This is explored through the true story of a lost Corona spy satellite in the 1960s. These satellites dropped film capsules back to Earth to be caught mid-air by aircraft. In 1964, one such capsule malfunctioned and reentered uncontrollably, landing on the border of Venezuela and Colombia. Local farmers found the strange object, which was labeled with a stern warning in multiple languages threatening prosecution for tampering with U.S. government property. The farmers, unimpressed, pried it open, took some gold-plated discs, and used the parachute for their horses. When the capsule was eventually returned, the U.S. government learned a valuable lesson in human psychology. They changed the labels on future capsules, removing the threats and instead offering a reward for the capsule's safe return to a U.S. embassy. The book highlights that for a successful delivery, especially from space, technical solutions are only half the battle; understanding human motivation is just as critical.
When the Ground Itself Becomes the Problem
Key Insight 4
Narrator: Not all problems in the book are about active tasks; some are about preventing things from happening. In "How to Keep Your House from Moving," Munroe delves into the slow, inexorable drift of tectonic plates and its bizarre legal implications. While property lines are anchored to the ground and move with it, this system breaks down in the face of landslides.
The book presents the strange case of Joannou v. City of Rancho Palos Verdes. In the 1950s, road construction triggered a slow-motion landslide that, over decades, moved an entire neighborhood downhill. Some houses drifted hundreds of feet, eventually ending up on land owned by the city. The city demanded the homeowners leave. The residents sued, citing California’s Cullen Earthquake Act, a law designed to redraw property lines after sudden land shifts. However, in 2013, a court ruled against them. The judge stated that the law only applied to sudden events like earthquakes, not gradual movement. Because the landslide was slow, the homeowners were held responsible for their drifting property. This case perfectly illustrates how our legal and social systems are often unprepared for slow, large-scale geological change, leaving people in impossibly absurd situations.
Applying Absurdity to Human Systems
Key Insight 5
Narrator: Munroe’s analytical lens isn't limited to physics; he also applies it to human behavior and social systems with equally insightful results. In "How to Play Tag," he analyzes the game's dynamics by pitting different types of runners against each other. A sprinter like Usain Bolt could easily escape a long-distance runner like Hicham El Guerrouj, but only for a short time. El Guerrouj’s superior endurance would inevitably allow him to catch the exhausted sprinter. The game would then reach a stalemate, with the faster but less enduring player unable to ever tag the marathoner.
The chapter explores increasingly absurd escape strategies, from buying houses hundreds of miles apart to embarking on a 14,000-mile walk from South Africa to Russia. Yet, the final solution offered is the most profound. Instead of an endless, globe-spanning chase, the players could simply agree to live in the same neighborhood and trade off being "It" with a friendly high five each day. This simple conclusion reveals a deeper truth that runs through the book: often, the most elegant solution to a complex, adversarial problem is not a more advanced strategy or a bigger machine, but simple cooperation.
Conclusion
Narrator: The single most important takeaway from How To is that asking absurd questions is a powerful tool for understanding. By pushing everyday problems to their physical and logical limits, Randall Munroe reveals the fundamental principles that govern our world, from the conservation of energy to the complexities of human psychology. He embraces a core idea expressed in the book: "Physics doesn’t care if your question is weird. It just gives you the answer, without judging."
Ultimately, the book is not a serious guide to building a lava moat or flying your house. It is a challenge to its readers to cultivate a sense of playful curiosity. It encourages us to look at the world with an analytical eye, to question the constraints we take for granted, and to appreciate the mind-boggling scale of the forces that shape our reality. The book's true impact is in reminding us that sometimes, the most impractical thought experiments are the ones that lead to the most practical and profound insights.