
Headscarves and Hymens
12 minWhy the Middle East Needs a Sexual Revolution
Introduction
Narrator: A woman is in bed with her husband. As he uses her body for his own pleasure, her mind drifts. She notices a spiderweb on the ceiling. She thinks about how he always refuses to prolong their intimacy for her own satisfaction. The call to prayer interrupts them. He rolls over, and she dutifully gets up to prepare his coffee. When she returns to the bedroom, she finds him dead. Her reaction is not one of grief, but of quiet, calm liberation. She simply pours herself a cup of coffee. This haunting scene from a short story by Egyptian writer Alifa Rifaat is the entry point into a fierce and unflinching examination of misogyny. In her book, Headscarves and Hymens, author and activist Mona Eltahawy argues that this quiet desperation is the product of a trifecta of oppression—the state, the street, and the home—which work together to control and crush women. She posits that the Middle East and North Africa are in desperate need of a sexual revolution.
The Trifecta of Misogyny Fuels a Culture of Hate
Key Insight 1
Narrator: Eltahawy argues that the oppression of women in the Arab world is not a side effect of political turmoil but a foundational pillar of the society itself. She identifies a "trifecta of misogyny" where the state, the street, and the home collaborate to enforce women's subjugation. This system is fueled by a toxic combination of cultural traditions and religious interpretations that are fundamentally hostile to women.
Eltahawy’s argument is shaped by her own "traumatization into feminism." At age fifteen, she moved from London to Saudi Arabia. There, her mother, a successful physician and the family's breadwinner, was forbidden from driving. Eltahawy witnessed a society where women were infantilized, requiring male permission for basic activities like opening a bank account. This experience revealed that misogyny wasn't an isolated issue but a pervasive, systemic reality.
The book argues that this hatred is not a response to women having freedoms, but the very reason those freedoms are denied. It is a regional phenomenon, transcending specific countries or religious sects. Data from the World Economic Forum's Global Gender Gap Report supports this, showing that not a single Arab country ranks in the top one hundred for gender equality, with nations like Yemen and Morocco at the very bottom. Eltahawy concludes that for women in the region, a "double revolution" is necessary: one against the political dictatorships and another against the patriarchal dictators in their own societies.
The Veil and the Street Are Battlegrounds for Control
Key Insight 2
Narrator: Eltahawy explores the public spaces where this control is most visible: the veiling of women's bodies and the constant threat of harassment on the street. She deconstructs the hijab and niqab not as simple pieces of cloth, but as complex symbols. For some, they represent piety or identity; for others, they are a "white flag" of surrender to conservative patriarchal forces.
Her own journey with the hijab illustrates this complexity. She began wearing it for nine years, partly as a defense against harassment in Saudi Arabia. However, she was once groped during the Hajj pilgrimage in Mecca, the holiest site in Islam, proving that the veil offers no real protection. This experience, along with a tragic 2002 fire at a Saudi girls' school where morality police blocked girls from escaping because they weren't properly veiled, solidified her view. In that moment, the headscarf became worth more than a girl's life.
This control extends to the street, which becomes a space of terror rather than freedom. Eltahawy presents staggering statistics, including a 2013 UN report finding that 99.3 percent of Egyptian women have experienced sexual harassment. This is not random violence but a tool to police women's presence in public. Eltahawy herself was brutally beaten and sexually assaulted by riot police on Cairo's Mohamed Mahmoud Street in 2011. This personal trauma connects the dots between state-sanctioned violence and street-level misogyny, revealing them as two heads of the same beast, both aiming to force women out of the public square and back into submission.
The Obsession with Virginity and Honor Sanctions Violence at Home
Key Insight 3
Narrator: The book argues that the home, often idealized as a sanctuary, is frequently the most dangerous place for women. This danger is rooted in a cultural obsession with female virginity and family honor, policed by what Eltahawy calls "The God of Virginity." A woman's hymen is not considered her own; it belongs to her family, and its "purity" is paramount.
This obsession fuels horrific practices like Female Genital Mutilation (FGM). Eltahawy shares the story of Soheir el-Batea, a thirteen-year-old Egyptian girl who died in 2013 during an FGM procedure performed by a doctor. Despite FGM being illegal in Egypt, the doctor and her father were acquitted, a stark illustration of how deeply entrenched the practice remains.
This culture of honor also enables domestic violence and "honor killings." The book recounts the gut-wrenching story of Lama al-Ghamdi, a five-year-old Saudi girl tortured and murdered by her own father, a self-proclaimed cleric, who suspected she was no longer a virgin. He was sentenced to a mere eight years in prison, and the sentence was later overturned. In many countries, personal status laws derived from religious interpretations give men immense power in marriage, divorce, and custody, trapping women in abusive situations. Laws that allow a rapist to escape punishment by marrying his victim, as was the case in Jordan, further demonstrate how the legal system prioritizes male honor over female safety.
The Fight for Mobility Is a Revolution on Wheels
Key Insight 4
Narrator: For Eltahawy, nowhere is the restriction of female autonomy more absurdly symbolized than in Saudi Arabia's former ban on women driving. The fight for the right to drive becomes a microcosm of the larger struggle for freedom of movement and basic human rights. The regime often justified the ban by claiming society was "not ready," a narrative Eltahawy dismantles as a flimsy excuse to maintain patriarchal control.
The book chronicles the long history of activism against the ban. In 1990, forty-seven Saudi women courageously drove through the capital, Riyadh. They were swiftly punished, denounced as whores in mosques, fired from their jobs, and banned from travel. Two decades later, in 2011, activist Manal al-Sharif reignited the movement with her "Women2Drive" campaign. She filmed herself driving and posted it on YouTube, an act of defiance that landed her in jail for nine days.
These acts of protest were not just about cars; they were a direct challenge to the male guardianship system, which treats women as perpetual minors. Eltahawy points out the hypocrisy of the international community, which often overlooks Saudi Arabia's abysmal human rights record due to economic interests in oil and arms. The fight for mobility, whether through driving or participating in sports, is a fight to be recognized as a full citizen, capable of navigating the world on one's own terms.
A True Revolution Must Be Fought in the Mind and the Bedroom
Key Insight 5
Narrator: Eltahawy’s ultimate argument is that political change is meaningless without a corresponding social and sexual revolution. The fight for freedom cannot stop at the front door; it must enter the home, the mind, and the bedroom. She calls for women to "speak for yourself," to break the taboos surrounding their bodies and sexuality.
She shares her own deeply personal journey of unlearning the guilt and shame associated with sex, a struggle that took nearly two decades. This personal liberation, she argues, is political. When women are taught to be silent about their bodies—whether about pleasure or pain—it reinforces the power structures that oppress them. Acts that seem shocking, like Aliaa Elmahdy’s nude protest online, are framed not as provocations but as necessary acts of resistance against a society that is more outraged by a naked body than by violence against women.
The book concludes that the real battle is between patriarchy and the women who refuse to accept it. This requires a feminist reckoning with culture, religion, and politics. It requires creating new language to talk about sex, demanding comprehensive sex education, and building communities where women can share their stories without fear. As one young woman named Alaa expressed in a support group, "I am full of so much rage!" It is this rage, Eltahawy insists, that will ultimately free their countries.
Conclusion
Narrator: The single most important takeaway from Headscarves and Hymens is that misogyny is not a peripheral issue but the central, organizing principle of power in many societies, and it cannot be dismantled by political reform alone. A true revolution requires a frontal assault on the cultural and religious norms that police women's bodies, from what they wear to whom they love.
Mona Eltahawy leaves readers with a powerful challenge. The fight she describes is not confined by geography; it is a global struggle against patriarchy. The question then becomes not just about understanding the oppression of women "over there," but about recognizing and confronting the trifecta of misogyny—in the state, on the street, and in the home—wherever it exists. What are you doing to tear down the walls of silence in your own world?