Aibrary Logo
Podcast thumbnail

Guantánamo Diary

8 min

Introduction

Narrator: On an August night in 2003, in a secret interrogation room in Guantánamo Bay, a commando team bursts in. They violently assault a detainee, breaking his ribs. They blindfold him, shackle him, and drag him to a high-speed boat. For three hours, they beat him, force him to drink salt water until he vomits, and threaten him with death. This was not a rogue operation; it was a meticulously planned part of his interrogation. The man at the center of this ordeal was Mohamedou Ould Slahi, and his story, written by his own hand from inside his cell, challenges the very foundations of justice in the post-9/11 world. His book, Guantánamo Diary, is a harrowing, firsthand account of a journey through the darkest corners of the war on terror.

The Unraveling of a Life on Flimsy Suspicion

Key Insight 1

Narrator: Before he was detainee 760, Mohamedou Ould Slahi was an electrical engineer who had returned to his home country of Mauritania after years of studying and working in Germany. His ordeal began not with a crime, but with a suspicion. In January 2000, he was arrested in Senegal at the request of the United States, who suspected his involvement in the "Millennium Plot" to bomb LAX airport. The evidence was tenuous, based on distant associations. After weeks of interrogation by Senegalese, Mauritanian, and American agents, authorities concluded there was no basis for the accusations, and he was released.

For over a year, he lived freely, working and being with his family. But after the 9/11 attacks, the world changed. In September 2001, while helping to organize his niece's wedding, he was summoned by Mauritanian authorities and arrested again, once more at the request of the U.S. This time, there would be no release. Despite his own government finding no evidence against him, they were pressured to cooperate. Slahi’s story begins here, not as a hardened enemy combatant, but as a man caught in a global dragnet, where suspicion was enough to erase a life.

The Architecture of Rendition and Dehumanization

Key Insight 2

Narrator: Slahi's journey into the abyss of secret detention reveals a calculated system of dehumanization. On Mauritania's Independence Day, a day meant to celebrate sovereignty, he was handed over to American agents. This was the start of his "extraordinary rendition." He was flown to a prison in Jordan, a country known for brutal interrogations. For eight months, he was held incommunicado, hidden from the International Red Cross, and subjected to psychological torment.

From Jordan, he was flown to Bagram Air Base in Afghanistan, and finally, on August 5, 2002, he arrived at Guantánamo Bay. The process was designed to break a person before the first question was ever asked. He describes being stripped naked, forced into a diaper, shackled, and fitted with blackout goggles and earmuffs for the long flight. This systematic stripping of identity, dignity, and sensory perception was not random cruelty; it was the standard operating procedure for transporting a human being deemed outside the protection of the law. He had become a piece of cargo in a global network of secret prisons.

The 'Special Interrogation Plan' and the Fabrication of Guilt

Key Insight 3

Narrator: At Guantánamo, Slahi was designated a "special project," and in 2003, a "special interrogation plan" was personally approved for him by Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld. This was a license for systematic torture. For months, he endured extreme isolation, sleep deprivation, frigid temperatures, stress positions, death threats, and sexual humiliation.

The psychological torture was just as severe. In one of the book's most chilling moments, interrogators presented him with a forged letter, seemingly from the U.S. government, stating that his mother would be arrested and brought to a facility like Guantánamo if he didn't cooperate. The interrogators knew this was his breaking point. This was not about finding the truth; it was about manufacturing a confession. The plan culminated in a staged abduction, where he was taken out on a boat and subjected to a mock execution. Under this immense pressure, Slahi began to tell his interrogators what they wanted to hear, fabricating stories and plots to make the torture stop.

A Crisis of Conscience Within the System

Key Insight 4

Narrator: The brutality of Slahi's treatment was so extreme that it created a crisis of conscience within the very system designed to prosecute him. Lt. Col. Stuart Couch, a devout Christian and military prosecutor, was assigned Slahi's case. Motivated by a deep sense of patriotism after a friend died piloting one of the planes on 9/11, Couch was determined to bring terrorists to justice.

However, as he reviewed the evidence, he uncovered the truth of the "special interrogation plan." He found the documentation of the threats against Slahi's mother and the details of his torture. Couch concluded that the case was built on evidence obtained through methods that were not only illegal but profoundly immoral. Believing that a conviction based on torture would be a betrayal of American values and his own faith, he refused to proceed. In an extraordinary act of moral courage, Lt. Col. Couch withdrew from the case, effectively halting the military's effort to prosecute Mohamedou Ould Slahi.

The Redacted Truth and the Power of Forgiveness

Key Insight 5

Narrator: Guantánamo Diary is not just a story; it is a physical artifact of injustice. Slahi wrote the 466-page manuscript by hand in 2005, in English, his fourth language, which he largely perfected while in U.S. custody. Before it could be published, it was subjected to intense government censorship. The final book is filled with over 2,500 black-bar redactions. Names, places, and entire passages are blotted out, serving as a constant, visual reminder that the full truth is still being concealed and that the author's fate was still controlled by his captors.

Yet, what is perhaps most astonishing is the book's final message. In an author's note conveyed through his lawyers, Slahi states that he holds no grudge against anyone he mentions. He expresses a dream of one day sitting down with his captors and interrogators to share a cup of tea, believing they could learn from one another. After enduring unimaginable cruelty, his final word is not a call for revenge, but an appeal for reconciliation and understanding.

Conclusion

Narrator: The single most important takeaway from Guantánamo Diary is the profound human cost of abandoning the rule of law. It reveals how, in the name of security, a system can be created that not only sanctions torture but relies on it, corrupting the very principles of justice it claims to defend. Slahi’s story is a testament to the resilience of the human spirit, but it is also a stark warning about the ease with which a nation can lose its moral compass.

The book leaves us with a challenging question: What is our responsibility for actions taken in our name but hidden from our view? Mohamedou Ould Slahi was finally released in 2016, after 14 years without ever being charged with a crime. But his diary remains a permanent record of injustice, forcing us to confront a dark chapter in history and to ask whether we have truly learned its lessons.

00:00/00:00