Aibrary Logo
Podcast thumbnail

Death's Summer Coat

9 min

What the History of Death and Dying Can Tell Us about Life and Living

Introduction

Narrator: Imagine a box-like theatre in Los Angeles, located behind a fence topped with razor wire. Inside, a strange event is unfolding: a "death cabaret." Scholars, morticians, and a curious public have gathered for the first-ever Death Salon, an event dedicated to breaking the profound silence that surrounds mortality in the modern Western world. This scene, both bizarre and deeply necessary, captures the central puzzle of our time: in an age of unprecedented medical advancement and comfort, why have we become so terrified of discussing the one certainty we all share?

In her book, Death's Summer Coat: What the History of Death and Dying Can Tell Us about Life and Living, author Brandy Schillace embarks on a journey to answer this question. She argues that our culture's avoidance of death has left us unprepared for grief and disconnected from one of life's most fundamental experiences. The book reveals that by looking to history and other cultures, we can find new ways to confront mortality, not with fear, but with understanding, connection, and even beauty.

The Great Western Silence: How We Learned to Fear Death

Key Insight 1

Narrator: In the modern West, death has become a taboo. It is a subject whispered in euphemisms, hidden behind hospital doors, and treated as a medical failure rather than a natural part of life. Schillace argues this silence is a relatively new phenomenon, born from wealth, advanced healthcare, and a cultural obsession with prolonging life at all costs. This avoidance creates a profound irony, best illustrated by the personal story of the author’s best friend's mother. As she was dying of breast cancer, she repeatedly tried to talk about her own death—to express her fears, make preparations, and find peace. Yet, those around her, wanting to be positive, consistently shut her down, telling her not to speak of it. She was preparing to meet death, but was forbidden from talking about it.

This story reveals a deep cultural sickness. We have built a protective barrier against the reality of death, but in doing so, we have left ourselves emotionally and spiritually defenseless when it inevitably arrives. This avoidance prevents the dying from processing their own mortality and robs the living of the tools needed to grieve, heal, and find meaning in loss.

The World's Wisdom: Re-familiarizing Death Through Ritual

Key Insight 2

Narrator: While the West has worked to sanitize and hide death, many cultures around the world have done the opposite, intentionally keeping death close to make it familiar. Schillace takes readers on a global tour of these practices, revealing that our way is far from the only way. One of the most powerful examples comes from the Toraja people of Sulawesi, Indonesia. For the Toraja, life revolves around death, but not in a morbid sense. When a person dies, they are not immediately considered "dead." Instead, they are thought to be "sick" or "asleep." The body is embalmed and kept in the family home, sometimes for years, until the family can afford a proper funeral ceremony. During this time, the deceased is symbolically fed, cared for, and treated as a continued presence in the family.

This practice, which might seem shocking to an outsider, serves a vital purpose. It transforms death from an abrupt, terrifying event into a gradual process. It allows the family to grieve slowly and maintain a connection with their loved one. By keeping the corpse integrated with the living, the Toraja make death intimate and familiar, stripping it of the alien terror it holds in cultures that rush to dispose of the body. Their rituals show that when death is kept near, it ceases to be a stranger.

From Good Death to Medical Battle: Tracing the Historical Shift

Key Insight 3

Narrator: The modern Western fear of death is not an accident; it is the result of centuries of historical change. Schillace traces this evolution, showing how the concept of a "good death" has been radically transformed. In the Middle Ages, a "tame death" was one where the individual knew it was coming, had time to prepare their soul, and died surrounded by their community. Death was a public, religious event. Even in the face of the Black Death, which shattered societal norms, the focus remained on the soul's journey.

However, the Reformation challenged Catholic rituals, the Enlightenment prioritized science over faith, and the Industrial Revolution brought a new focus on medicine. Death slowly moved from the priest's domain to the doctor's. This shift is starkly illustrated by the case of Terri Schiavo, a woman in a vegetative state whose feeding tube was only removed after a seven-year legal and political battle. Her case became a symbol of how modern medicine views death as an enemy to be fought at all costs, with technology capable of keeping a body functioning long after any meaningful life has ceased. Death is no longer a natural process to be navigated, but a medical problem to be solved, often at the expense of peace and dignity.

The Doctor's Dilemma: When Saving a Life Clashes with Honoring a Death

Key Insight 4

Narrator: The medicalization of death has placed physicians in an incredibly difficult position, caught between their duty to preserve life and the patient's right to a peaceful end. This tension is powerfully captured in the story of a Jehovah's Witness who required routine surgery. Before the operation, she signed an informed consent document stating that, due to her religious beliefs, she would refuse a blood transfusion under any circumstances. During the surgery, she began to bleed uncontrollably. Her husband, seeing his wife dying, begged the doctors to give her blood. The medical team was thrown into an ethical crisis. Should they honor the patient's clearly stated, autonomous wish, or should they violate it to save her life?

This case highlights the central conflict of modern dying. Doctors are trained to fight, to use every tool at their disposal. Yet, as Dr. Rachel Naomi Remen discovered, this professional detachment can become a burden. After being taught as an intern to suppress her emotions, she later realized that her stoic composure when delivering bad news left grieving families feeling more isolated. The system trains doctors to be technicians of the body, but it often fails to equip them to be guides for the human soul, leaving both patients and physicians in a "wilderness of dying" without a map.

Reclaiming the Conversation: The Rise of New Death Rituals

Key Insight 5

Narrator: In response to this cultural silence and medicalization, a "death-positive" movement is emerging, creating new spaces for old conversations. In 2011, a former British council worker named Jon Underwood was inspired by the work of a Swiss sociologist to create a simple forum for people to talk about mortality. He called it a "Death Cafe." The idea was straightforward: gather in a neutral space, drink tea, eat cake, and discuss death. There is no agenda, no objective, and no expert leading the conversation. The movement exploded in popularity, spreading across the globe.

Alongside Death Cafes, initiatives like "Death Over Dinner" encourage people to have these vital conversations with loved ones over a meal. These new rituals are not about being morbid; they are about living more fully. By providing a framework to discuss end-of-life wishes, fears, and beliefs, they empower individuals to take control of their own narrative. They prove that talking about death doesn't hasten its arrival; rather, it prepares us to face it with more clarity, connection, and peace.

Conclusion

Narrator: The single most important takeaway from Death's Summer Coat is that our relationship with death directly shapes our relationship with life. By pushing death away, sanitizing it, and refusing to speak its name, we have not conquered it; we have only impoverished our own lives, leaving ourselves isolated in our grief and fearful of our own mortality. The book argues that the path forward is not to find a cure for death, but to rediscover the wisdom of embracing it as an integral part of the human experience.

Schillace leaves us with a profound challenge. The work of changing our culture is not just for academics, morticians, or doctors. It begins with the simple, courageous act of conversation. The book asks us to consider: How can you begin to break the silence in your own life? Who can you invite to have a conversation about what it means to live well, and ultimately, to die well?

00:00/00:00