
Catch and Kill
9 minLies, Spies, and a Conspiracy to Protect Predators
Introduction
Narrator: Imagine two men, immigrants from the former Soviet Union, meeting in a dimly lit Brooklyn restaurant. They are private investigators, and one, Roman Khaykin, has a new client. He leans in and tells his colleague, Igor Ostrovskiy, that he’s into some “cool shit. Some dark stuff.” He talks about advanced, and likely illegal, surveillance methods—tracking phones, pulling bank records. Ostrovskiy is skeptical, but he needs the work. He doesn't know it yet, but he is being recruited into a sophisticated, well-funded machine designed not just to gather information, but to silence victims and kill the truth.
This shadowy meeting is the opening scene in a real-life political thriller documented in Ronan Farrow's book, Catch and Kill: Lies, Spies, and a Conspiracy to Protect Predators. The book reveals that the conspiracy to protect powerful men like Harvey Weinstein wasn't just a matter of secrets and influence. It was a full-blown intelligence operation, complete with spies, counter-spies, and a network of enablers in the highest echelons of media and law.
A Shadow Army Was Mobilized to Bury the Truth
Key Insight 1
Narrator: The story of Harvey Weinstein's downfall is not just about one man's crimes; it's about the elaborate, corporate-funded system he built to conceal them. This system was a literal "army of spies." Farrow’s investigation reveals that Weinstein hired Black Cube, a private intelligence firm run by former Israeli Mossad agents. Their mission was clear: find out which journalists were investigating Weinstein and identify his accusers to discredit, intimidate, or silence them.
One of their targets was Ben Wallace, a reporter for New York magazine who was also digging into the Weinstein rumors. Operatives from Black Cube, using false identities, repeatedly contacted Wallace. One agent, posing as a women's rights advocate named Anna, met with him in coffee shops and hotel bars, trying to extract information about his sources and the scope of his story. This wasn't just a casual inquiry; it was a professional intelligence operation designed to neutralize a threat. This same machinery was deployed against Weinstein's accusers, like actress Rose McGowan, who was contacted by operatives under false pretenses in an attempt to learn what she planned to reveal. This network of spies demonstrates that Weinstein wasn't just reacting to a story; he was waging a proactive, clandestine war against the truth.
Media Gatekeepers Became Part of the Conspiracy
Key Insight 2
Narrator: Before Farrow could even begin to untangle Weinstein's web, he ran into a wall within his own network, NBC News. This revealed a different kind of conspiracy—one of complicity and convenience within the media itself. In late 2016, Farrow and his producer were set to air a story about how colleges were mishandling sexual assault cases. But it was abruptly shelved. The reason? The infamous Access Hollywood tape had just been released, featuring Donald Trump and NBC's own Billy Bush. The network was suddenly terrified of the topic of sexual assault. Farrow texted his producer in disbelief, "They’re scared of sexual assault?" It became clear that media politics and public relations often took precedence over hard-hitting journalism.
This pattern of avoidance intensified when Farrow began investigating Weinstein. Executives at NBC, including president Noah Oppenheim, grew hesitant. They called the subject "too dark" for morning television. Farrow was repeatedly told to put the story on the "back burner." The pressure wasn't just internal. Weinstein himself was calling top executives like Andy Lack and Phil Griffin, leveraging his power and friendships to get the story killed. This shows how the "catch and kill" system wasn't just run by tabloids; it was enabled by mainstream news organizations that chose to look the other way.
Cracks in the Wall of Silence Began to Appear
Key Insight 3
Narrator: Despite the institutional resistance, Farrow and his producer, Rich McHugh, pressed on. The breakthrough came not from A-list celebrities, but from former Miramax employees who had witnessed the culture of abuse firsthand. In a Santa Monica hotel room, Farrow interviewed Dennis Rice, a former marketing executive for Weinstein. Rice nervously admitted that at Miramax, there was always money set aside to take care of "indiscretions," a category that included everything from bullying to sexual harassment. He confessed to seeing Weinstein "inappropriately touching" young women.
Another producer, Dede Nickerson, independently confirmed this culture of predation. She told Farrow that it was common knowledge that Weinstein was dangerous around women. With a chilling finality, she said, "Everybody knew." These interviews were monumental. For the first time, people from inside the machine were willing to go on camera and confirm the rumors that had circulated for decades. Their courage provided the crucial corroboration Farrow needed to prove this was not just a series of isolated incidents, but a systemic pattern of abuse enabled by a culture of silence.
The "Smoking Gun" Tape Was Met with a Kill Order
Key Insight 4
Narrator: The investigation reached a critical turning point with the story of Ambra Battilana Gutierrez, a model who had reported Weinstein to the police in 2015. After Weinstein allegedly groped her, the NYPD had her wear a wire and meet him again. Farrow managed to track down Gutierrez, who, despite being bound by a million-dollar NDA, eventually played him the audio. On the recording, Weinstein's voice is unmistakable. He admits to groping her the day before and pressures her to come into his hotel room, saying, "I’m used to that. Come on. Please."
Farrow now had a "smoking gun"—an audio recording of Weinstein admitting to assault. He and McHugh took this explosive evidence to their superiors at NBC. But instead of greenlighting the story, the executives doubled down on their resistance. They claimed they couldn't use the tape and ordered Farrow to stop reporting. In a stunning moment, an NBC executive told him to "give it a rest." They had the evidence, the on-the-record sources, and the tape, but the network officially killed the story. Farrow was told his contract would be terminated if he took the story elsewhere. The "catch and kill" machine had won, at least for the moment.
The Truth Found a Way Out
Key Insight 5
Narrator: Refusing to be silenced, Farrow took his meticulously reported story to The New Yorker, a publication with a reputation for backing its reporters. There, editor David Remnick recognized the story's importance and gave it the institutional support NBC had denied. The story was published, and the impact was immediate and seismic. It helped ignite the #MeToo movement, toppling not just Weinstein but powerful men across industries.
The story also had a strange and powerful ripple effect. One of the spies from the beginning of the story, Igor Ostrovskiy, had been working for Black Cube through a subcontractor. He had been assigned to surveil Farrow and his sources. But Ostrovskiy, an immigrant who fled a country with a state-controlled press, grew deeply troubled. He saw the same tactics of suppression being used in his new home to protect a predator. In a remarkable turn, he became a source for Farrow, leaking information about the spy operation designed to stop the story. He felt he had a duty to protect the free press, which he called a vital pillar of democracy. The very machinery designed to kill the story contained a man whose conscience led him to help it see the light.
Conclusion
Narrator: The single most important takeaway from Catch and Kill is that powerful predators are not lone wolves. They are apex predators who thrive within a carefully constructed ecosystem of enablers—lawyers who weaponize the law, media executives who trade access for silence, and private spies who hunt and intimidate victims. Ronan Farrow’s book is a chilling exposé of this machinery, showing that the fight for truth is often a battle against not just one person, but an entire system built to protect the powerful.
The book leaves us with a challenging question: If it took this much evidence, this much risk, and this much courage to expose just one predator, how many other systems of suppression are operating in the shadows right now? It’s a stark reminder that a free and fearless press isn't a given; it's something that must be fought for, one source, one story, and one act of courage at a time.