
Big Friendship
14 minHow We Keep Each Other Close
Introduction
Narrator: Imagine a weekend getaway to a beautiful spa, a trip designed to reconnect with your closest friend. But instead of relaxation, the air is thick with tension. Conversations are stilted, laughter is forced, and you both feel a profound sense of distance, even while sharing a mud bath. This isn't a hypothetical scenario; it was the painful reality for Aminatou Sow and Ann Friedman, two friends whose deep, affirming bond had quietly deteriorated into a state of disrepair. They realized they lacked the words, the societal scripts, to describe what was happening. Their friendship was one of the most important relationships in their lives, yet they had no framework for navigating its near-collapse.
This crisis is the starting point for their book, Big Friendship: How We Keep Each Other Close. It’s a candid and insightful exploration that gives a name to these profound, complex, and essential platonic partnerships. The book argues that a "Big Friendship" is a relationship of immense value, one that deserves the same level of care, intention, and, when necessary, repair that we dedicate to our romantic and familial bonds.
Big Friendships Are Forged in a Spark and Solidified as Chosen Family
Key Insight 1
Narrator: A Big Friendship doesn't just happen; it often begins with a "spark," an immediate and effortless connection. For Ann and Aminatou, this spark ignited in 2009 at a Gossip Girl viewing party in Washington, D.C. Ann, a journalist feeling adrift in the city, was immediately drawn to Aminatou's wit and her bold "CHUCK + BLAIR" t-shirt. Aminatou, an international student navigating a challenging job market, found a kindred spirit in Ann. They met during a period of transition and restlessness, a time when both were searching for deeper connection.
This initial meeting quickly blossomed into obsession. They became "social initiators," proactively making and keeping plans, a practice they describe as their shared love language. They understood, as research by Professor Jeffrey Hall confirms, that friendship requires a significant time investment—hundreds of hours to build the kind of closeness they were forging. This time was often spent in the comfort of their apartments, what they call essential "couch time," sharing life stories, inside jokes, and quiet moments that built a foundation of trust.
This intense bonding led them to become each other's "chosen family." They filled gaps in each other's lives, providing the kind of unwavering support that attachment theory describes as a "secure base" and a "safe harbor." When Ann went through a difficult breakup, Aminatou was her rock, helping her move and re-establish her life. When Aminatou had a panic attack after a strained meeting with her father, Ann’s calm, non-judgmental presence provided immediate comfort. They created a bond that felt as foundational and non-negotiable as family, a relationship they were determined to protect.
Shine Theory Is a Radical Practice of Mutual Investment
Key Insight 2
Narrator: Early in their careers, both Ann and Aminatou faced professional challenges, from workplace sexism to precarious visa situations. Lacking formal mentorship, they leaned on each other, developing a powerful practice they named "Shine Theory." The core principle is simple but transformative: "I don’t shine if you don’t shine." Instead of viewing other talented people, especially other women, as competition, Shine Theory advocates for mutual investment in each other's success.
This theory was born from necessity. When Aminatou was suddenly laid off, jeopardizing her visa, her friendweb, activated by Ann, rallied to provide legal help and job leads. Later, when Ann received a major job offer, she was hesitant to negotiate for a higher salary. Aminatou and their friends coached her, sharing advice and building her confidence until she successfully secured a six-figure salary with benefits.
Shine Theory is a deliberate rejection of the scarcity mindset that often pits marginalized people against each other. It’s about collaboration over competition. This can be as direct as sharing salary information to fight pay inequity, a practice inspired by activists like Lilly Ledbetter. It can also be a strategy for amplification, as seen in the Obama White House, where female staffers made a pact to repeat each other's points in meetings and give credit by name, ensuring their ideas were heard. Shine Theory isn't about transactional networking; it's a deep, long-term commitment to seeing your friends succeed, knowing that their success elevates everyone.
Friendships Must Stretch to Survive Change and Complexity
Key Insight 3
Narrator: No friendship exists in a vacuum. It is inevitably tested by life's changes, a process the authors call "stretching." A stretch is the adaptation required when circumstances change, such as a long-distance move or a health crisis. This concept became painfully real when Ann moved to Los Angeles and, soon after, Aminatou began suffering from a debilitating chronic illness.
Aminatou's health issues, eventually diagnosed as endometrial cancer, created a massive stretch. Ann, now thousands of miles away, struggled to provide support from a distance, feeling helpless. Aminatou had to learn to ask for and accept help, a difficult task for a fiercely independent person. The friendship had to adapt to new realities of "Good Days" and "Bad Days," requiring immense empathy and flexibility from both.
The authors distinguish stretching from straining. A stretch is mutual, with both friends making an effort to adapt. A strain, however, is one-sided and leads to resentment. This distinction is critical in managing not just one-on-one relationships but also the larger "friendweb"—the complex, interconnected network of a person's social world. Their "Desert Ladies" trip to Joshua Tree, which grew from an intimate gathering to a massive event, illustrated this perfectly. As the group expanded, unspoken conflicts and differing expectations created fault lines that strained individual relationships, including their own.
The Trapdoor of Racism Can Threaten Interracial Friendships
Key Insight 4
Narrator: While Ann and Aminatou initially built their bond on a "story of sameness," they eventually had to confront their most significant difference: race. The authors introduce the concept of the "trapdoor of racism," a term from critic Wesley Morris. It describes the constant, underlying awareness for a person of color that a friendship with a white person can be ruptured at any moment by an act of racial insensitivity.
This trapdoor swung open for Aminatou at a party at Ann's house. As she scanned the crowd, she had a sinking realization: she was the only Black person there. The feeling of isolation and discomfort was immediate and profound. It raised a painful question: How could her best friend, her chosen family, not have a more racially diverse social circle?
Bringing this up with Ann months later was difficult. Ann's initial defensiveness gave way to a pained apology, but the conversation highlighted the unequal emotional labor often present in interracial friendships. Ann had to confront her blind spots, while Aminatou had to navigate the exhaustion of explaining her experience. The book argues that for a Big Friendship to survive across racial lines, the white friend must commit to doing their own work, to listen without defensiveness, and to actively fight against the structural racism that creates these trapdoors in the first place.
No Friendship Is "Too Big to Fail"
Key Insight 5
Narrator: As their careers grew, Ann and Aminatou launched the popular podcast Call Your Girlfriend. The show, premised on their close bond, turned their friendship into a public brand. Listeners saw them as the pinnacle of platonic love. But behind the scenes, a dangerous gap was widening between their public persona and their private reality. The pressures of their individual lives, the physical distance, and the unresolved issues of race and illness created a perfect storm.
They had started to believe their own hype, joking that their friendship was "too big to fail." This, they write, is a lie. No relationship is immune to collapse. Their communication broke down into a destructive cycle. Fearing she would hurt Aminatou, Ann became withdrawn and indirect. Feeling abandoned, Aminatou pulled away further. The spa trip was a failed attempt to fix a problem they could no longer address on their own. Their friendship was failing, and the very podcast that celebrated it became a painful reminder of what they were losing.
The Long Haul Requires Active Maintenance and Repair
Key Insight 6
Narrator: Recognizing their friendship was on the brink of collapse, Ann made a radical suggestion: couples therapy. The decision to seek professional help was an acknowledgment that their Big Friendship was worth fighting for with the same tools society reserves for romantic partnerships. Therapy provided a structured, safe space to dismantle their "story of sameness" and confront their differences. Their therapist helped them identify their destructive emotional pattern and gave them the language to talk about their hurt.
This process of repair taught them that a lasting Big Friendship isn't about perfection; it's about resilience. It requires active, ongoing maintenance through what researcher Emily Langan identifies as three key practices. The first is ritual, like Ann's tradition of getting veggie burgers with her friend Josh. The second is assurances, the small, consistent verbal and nonverbal ways of saying "I'm committed to you." The third is openness, the vulnerability to share true feelings and needs. By investing in these practices, they were able to rebuild their bond, making it stronger and more honest than before.
Conclusion
Narrator: The single most important takeaway from Big Friendship is that these profound relationships are not passive occurrences but active commitments. They are a choice. They require the same intention, work, and willingness to repair that we dedicate to any other central relationship in our lives. A Big Friendship is an insurance policy against life’s hardships, a mirror for self-discovery, and a source of unparalleled joy.
The book gives us a new vocabulary to understand and honor these connections, challenging us to stop letting our most important friendships fade away by default. It leaves us with a powerful question: Which friendships in your life are you willing to stretch for, to invest in, and to fight for, not just for a season, but for the long haul?