
Barbarians at the Gate
10 minThe Fall of RJR Nabisco
Introduction
Narrator: Imagine being the CEO of a company that makes some of the world's most beloved products—Oreo cookies, Ritz crackers, and Winston cigarettes. You have a fleet of ten corporate jets, a stable of celebrity friends, and a board that lets you do almost anything you want. One day, concerned about a stagnant stock price, you propose a simple solution: you and your management team will buy the company yourselves. It seems like a clean, elegant fix. But what if that simple proposal wasn't an end, but a beginning? What if it was the spark that ignited the largest, most ferocious corporate battle in history, a war fought not over products or strategy, but over ego, power, and unimaginable sums of money?
This is the explosive scenario at the heart of Barbarians at the Gate: The Fall of RJR Nabisco by Bryan Burrough and John Helyar. The book provides a gripping, meticulously researched account of the leveraged buyout that became a defining moment of the 1980s, exposing the raw ambition and breathtaking excess of Wall Street's "Decade of Greed."
The Catalyst: A Culture of Excess
Key Insight 1
Narrator: The battle for RJR Nabisco could not have happened without its freewheeling CEO, F. Ross Johnson. He was the antithesis of the traditional, buttoned-down "company man." Johnson’s philosophy was simple: business should be a sophisticated, complicated party. He cultivated a culture of extravagance, famously maintaining the "RJR Air Force," a fleet of corporate jets used to fly his celebrity friends like Frank Sinatra and Don Meredith to golf tournaments and events. His attitude toward the company's iconic products was casual at best. "Some genius invented the Oreo," he once quipped. "We’re just living off the inheritance."
This style was forged early in his career. In the mid-1970s, while at the staid food company Standard Brands, Johnson clashed with its frugal chairman, Henry Weigl. Weigl was a traditionalist who scrutinized every expense, while Johnson believed in spending creatively to build relationships. The conflict culminated in a boardroom coup. Weigl tried to oust Johnson over his expense accounts, but Johnson, having rallied allies, turned the tables, presenting the board with a report on Weigl's own mismanagement. The board sided with Johnson, making him CEO and ushering in a new era of lavish spending. This victory taught Johnson a crucial lesson: with the right connections and a flair for the dramatic, the rules were his to make. It was this mindset—a focus on short-term action, personal enrichment, and a disregard for tradition—that led him to believe he could easily take RJR Nabisco private, underestimating the forces he was about to unleash.
The Barbarians Arrive: The Deal Becomes a War
Key Insight 2
Narrator: When Ross Johnson and his financial backer, Shearson Lehman Hutton, proposed a leveraged buyout (LBO) at $75 per share, they expected to control the process. They were wrong. The news of a company as large and stable as RJR Nabisco being "in play" was blood in the water for a new breed of Wall Street predator: the LBO firm. At the forefront was Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co., or KKR, led by the intensely ambitious Henry Kravis.
KKR had pioneered the LBO, a financial maneuver where a company is acquired using a significant amount of borrowed money, with the company's own assets serving as collateral. The goal was to take the company private, streamline its operations, and then sell it off in pieces or take it public again for a massive profit. When Kravis heard about Johnson's plan, he saw an opportunity he couldn't ignore. Just days after Johnson's proposal, KKR launched a stunning, unsolicited counter-bid of $90 per share.
With that single move, the game changed entirely. Johnson's private plan was now a public auction, and he had lost control. The "barbarians," as they were called, were at the gate. The conflict quickly became personal. In an early meeting, Johnson, ever the showman, casually flicked his Premier smokeless cigarette onto Kravis's priceless antique Oriental rug, a symbolic gesture of disrespect. The battle for RJR Nabisco was no longer just about money; it was a clash of titans, a war of egos that would be fought on the front pages of every newspaper in the country.
The Unraveling of Alliances: A War on All Fronts
Key Insight 3
Narrator: KKR's bid threw the financial world into a frenzy. Johnson's camp at Shearson, led by CEO Peter Cohen, was caught off guard. They had viewed the deal as their ticket to the big leagues of merchant banking, but now they were in a street fight with the most experienced LBO firm in the world. The situation was further complicated by the arrival of other bidders, including Ted Forstmann, a rival LBO specialist who viewed Kravis and his use of high-risk "junk bonds" with moral contempt.
The conflict reached a boiling point when details of the management group's proposed compensation package were leaked to The New York Times. The headline read: "NABISCO EXECUTIVES TO TAKE HUGE GAINS IN THEIR BUYOUT." The story revealed that Johnson and his top team stood to make hundreds of millions of dollars from the deal. The public outcry was immediate and intense. Johnson, once seen as a charismatic leader, was now portrayed as the poster child for corporate greed. The leak was a public relations disaster, enraging the RJR Nabisco board and turning public sentiment squarely against the management group. Johnson's dream of a quick, profitable buyout had devolved into a chaotic, multi-front war where loyalty was fleeting and every player was out for themselves.
The Final Showdown: Greed, Ego, and Exhaustion
Key Insight 4
Narrator: The RJR Nabisco board, now deeply distrustful of Johnson, took control of the auction. They set a final deadline and invited all parties to submit their "highest and best" offers. The final days were a blur of frantic, round-the-clock negotiations, driven by a toxic mix of exhaustion, ego, and paranoia. Bids were calculated, revised, and recalculated. Lawyers and bankers shuttled between the headquarters of the competing firms, sometimes getting stuck in Manhattan traffic and having to run blocks with bid packages worth billions.
The board's advisors, from the firms Lazard Frères and Dillon, Read & Co., struggled to evaluate the offers. The bids from KKR and the management group were incredibly complex and, when all the paper securities were valued, almost identical. The decision came down to more than just numbers. The board had to consider the quality of the securities offered, the long-term health of the company, and the public perception of the deal. In the final, chaotic round of bidding, the management group submitted a bid valued at $112 per share. For a moment, they thought they had won. But KKR, in a final, decisive move, submitted a bid of $109. Though technically lower, the board deemed KKR's offer to be of higher quality and, crucially, it did not have the taint of management's perceived greed. The board voted in favor of KKR.
The Aftermath: The End of an Era
Key Insight 5
Narrator: KKR's victory, for a record-breaking $25 billion, was the largest buyout in history. But the celebration was short-lived. The sheer size of the deal and the public backlash it generated had a chilling effect on Wall Street. The RJR Nabisco saga came to symbolize the peak of 1980s excess. Soon after, the junk bond market, which had fueled the LBO boom, collapsed. Major players like Drexel Burnham Lambert went bankrupt, and its star, Michael Milken, went to prison.
For RJR Nabisco, the buyout meant massive debt and a painful restructuring. The new CEO, Lou Gerstner, immediately began dismantling Ross Johnson's empire, selling off the corporate jets and moving the headquarters. For the city of Winston-Salem, the company's historic home, the buyout was a cultural tragedy, even as it made many long-time employees "reluctant millionaires." Ross Johnson walked away with over $50 million, but his reputation was shattered. The era of the swashbuckling corporate raider was over. The barbarians had won the battle, but their victory marked the end of the war and the dawn of a more sober, regulated era in American finance.
Conclusion
Narrator: The single most important takeaway from Barbarians at the Gate is that in the world of high finance, human nature—ego, greed, and personal animosity—can be a far more powerful force than logic, strategy, or even loyalty. The battle for RJR Nabisco was not just a transaction; it was a drama of Shakespearean proportions, driven by larger-than-life characters who were willing to risk everything for the ultimate prize.
The book remains a timeless cautionary tale about the dangers of unchecked ambition and the potential for financial engineering to overshadow fundamental business principles. It challenges us to ask a critical question: in the pursuit of shareholder value, where is the line between aggressive business and reckless greed, and who ultimately pays the price when that line is crossed?